The Stars of the Stage cigarette card set contains 12 cards, all of which can be found around the world in Red Dead Redemption 2. Collecting a complete set allows players to sell it to Phineas T. Ramsbottom for a reward, though the trouble is actually finding them.
Be sure to check out our guide on all cigarette card locations so you can find and complete the other sets to sell to Phineas T. Ramsbottom.
Before being able to find all the Stars of the Stage, players must first talk with Phineas T. Ramsbottom at the Flatneck Station in New Hanover. Speaking with Phineas begins the mission, Smoking and Other Hobbies, which spawns a few of the cards around the map.
All Stars of the Stage Cigarette Cards
The Stars of the Stage cigarette cards are scattered all across the map in Red Dead Redemption 2, even down in Blackwater and beyond. Because of this, it is advised that players wait until Blackwater is accessible before attempting to complete the set. The reward for completing the Stars of the Stage collection is Small Jewelry Bag and $50.
Original map credit: Powerpyx
Stars of the Stage card 1 – Laurence Dunn
The Laurence Dunn cigarette card can be found on the mantel in a farmhouse at the Southfield Flats north of Rhodes in Lemoyne.
Stars of the Stage card 2 – Louis Durand
The Louis Durand Stars of the Stage cigarette card can be found west of Van Horn Trading Post in New Hanover. Cross over the railway line and head toward the house on the following road. Find the card on the house’s porch.
Stars of the Stage card 3 – Jesse Raymond
The Jesse Raymond cigarette card can be found in the town of Tumbleweed in New Austin. Head to the north of Tumbleweed to find a burned house, inside is the card on a windowsill.
Stars of the Stage card 4 – Augusta Tremlow
The Augusta Tremlow cigarette card can be found on a property in the north of West Elizabeth. The property is north of the Little Creek River, just before the border to Ambarino. Climb the windmill on the property to find the cigarette card.
Stars of the Stage card 5 – Mabel Potter
The Mabel Potter cigarette card is in the west theatre in Saint Denis. Enter the theatre, purchase a ticket and then pass through the door way and immediately turn right. There will be a fireplace with a table below a painting, on the table is a card.
Stars of the Stage card 6 – Robin Koninsky
The Robin Koninsky cigarette card is in the Saint Denis thearter, but it is only available after unlocking the mission, Fatherhood and Other Dreams. All five performances must be viewed, at which point players can find the card on a table beside the stage.
Stars of the Stage card 7 – Isadore Reid
The Isadore Reid Stars of the Stage card is in Valentine, in a wagon to the west of town.
Stars of the Stage card 8 – Irene Grubb
The Irene Grubb cigarette card can be found in New Austin, to the south west of the Macfarlane’s Ranch. Go to the train station just near the ranch to find the card on a bench.
Stars of the Stage card 9 – Nettie Palmer
The Nettie Palmer cigarette card is found in Valentine, in the theatre tent at the west of town. Look under the seat where the projector sits.
Stars of the Stage card 10 – Jim Cobb
The Jim Cobb cigarette card can be found north of Eris Field in Lemoyne, at an abandoned house. Search the porch to find the card.
Stars of the Stage card 11 – Mittie Comstock
The Mittie Comstock cigarette card is in New Hanover, just north of The Heartlands down a little road south of the “H” in Hanover. Approach the house to find the card on a barrel.
Stars of the Stage card 12 – Robert Elliot Patchen
The Robert Elliot Patchen cigarette card is found in Rhodes, Lemoyne. North of Rhodes and south of Mattock Pond is a yellow hut, beside it is the card.
Check out the Shacknews Red Dead Redemption 2 walkthrough and guide for collectible guides, horse bonding explanations, and more!