Madden NFL 18 Review: Far From A Longshot

This years iteration of Madden NFL is the best in years. Our review.


Sports games are often looked at differently than many other genres. Most years, gamers pony up $60 for a chance to play with new team rosters and new player ratings. This is definitely true of the Madden franchise, but Madden NFL 18 breaks the traditional cycle of sports games with brand new gameplay experiences that will push the genre to new heights.

There are years when Madden is good, and there are years when it isn’t. Madden NFL 18 doesn’t fall into either category, because it is great. This year’s game has done long-time fans of the franchise a huge service by adding new ways to play video game football. It builds on the work of the past 3 iterations of the game while adding a whole new way to play Madden.


Madden NFL 18 adds a new single-player story mode called Longshot. Players are put into the role of Devin Wade, a quarterback from Texas with a checkered past, as he and his friend Colt try to make it all the way to the NFL. EA Tiburon set the bar high for this new mode in Madden and even enlisted the help of Amy Hennig and the folks at Bioware when it came time to develop the story. 

Longshot ends up being about three and a half hours long and features tons of environments and seamless transitions that keep players wanting more. EA spared no expense on the production of the game mode with Mahershala Ali leading a cast of voice actors that also includes NFL Hall-of-Famer Dan Marino. 

It isn’t the amount of money that went into Longshot that matters, it is the fact that it was a fun game to play. Throughout the campaign, players must make bold choices that matter. Those decisions shape the outcome of the story with multiple win states. Player choices and performance determines if Devin, Colt, or both are drafted into the NFL.

The last thing that really stands out about Longshot compared to other story modes in sports games is the variety of gameplay situations that keeps players fully immersed. The game is a playable film, and much like Naughty Dog’s Uncharted or Last of Us, there are times when a gameplay mechanic is introduced that is only used once at one specific moment of the game. This level of detail really makes Longshot stand out above all other story modes in the sports game genre. Players can even continue Devin's career in Ultimate Team or Franchise mode once they have completed the journey. Longshot is a welcome addition to the Madden NFL franchise and it will be interesting to see how it influences all EA Sports titles for years to come.

New Ways to Play

Madden Ultimate Team has become one of the most played modes in the game, and EA Tiburon has added a new way to play with friends called MUT Squads. This three-on-three online mode allows players to team up with friends against internet opponents. Each player has to choose a role: Offensive Captain, Defensive Captain, or Head Coach. Both captains take over the respective play-calling during the game, but the Head Coach focuses on setting the lineup before games start. MUT Squads is a welcome addition to the Madden franchise that brings together the fun of multiplayer gameplay with the already established Ultimate Team framework.

Another cool featured added to Madden NFL 18 is the Play Now Live mode. Players can jump into their favorite team’s season. After completing the game, players can continue on in Franchise mode with records, stats, and rosters reflecting the real NFL season. It is going to be a useful feature for ne’er-do-well Browns fans that dream of a day that their team will even make it to the playoffs. 

Improved Gameplay Mechanics

 The development team improved the overall gameplay experience by tweaking some hugely important aspects of controlling players on the field. Past iterations of the game felt slightly unbalanced and unrealistic at times and EA Tiburon has addressed many of those problems with new tackles, more intelligent character animations for swatting or intercepting the football, and tons of new offensive plays.

Two Minute Drill

Madden NFL 18 is one of the best Madden games I have ever played. It’s accessible to new players and offers brand new experiences for seasoned video game football vets. There are some years when Madden just doesn’t have the right feel, and I usually will be the first to tell folks to hold off on buying the game. But this is not one of those years. 2018 is coming, and Madden is ready to give you hours of awesome gameplay experiences.


Asif Khan is the CEO, EIC, and majority shareholder of Shacknews. He began his career in video game journalism as a freelancer in 2001 for Asif is a CPA and was formerly an investment adviser representative. After much success in his own personal investments, he retired from his day job in financial services and is currently focused on new private investments. His favorite PC game of all time is Duke Nukem 3D, and he is an unapologetic fan of most things Nintendo. Asif first frequented the Shack when it was sCary's Shugashack to find all things Quake. When he is not immersed in investments or gaming he is a purveyor of fine electronic music. Asif also has an irrational love of Cleveland sports.

Review for
Madden NFL 18
  • New Longshot campaign is a welcome addition
  • Gameplay tweaks make the game way more enjoyable
  • MUT Squads is a great new online mode
  • Game is more accessible to new players than ever before
  • Franchise mode largely unchanged
  • This game is not available for PC
From The Chatty
Hello, Meet Lola