ZeniMax Files Injunction to Completely Stop Sales of Oculus Rift

Apparently the $500 million judgement in their favor wasn't enough.

15

ZeniMax has filed an injunction, calling for all Oculus products that infringed code be pulled from shelves immediately. 

This proposal comes following the $500 million lawsuit that ZeniMax won against Oculus/facebook early this month. It seems as though ZeniMax doesn’t think the half a billion lawsuit was a large enough consequence for Oculus violating copyrights. 

As reported by Upload VR, the injunction calls for Oculus to be:

 “permanently enjoined, on a worldwide basis, from using…any of the Copyrighted Materials, including but not limited to (i) system software for Oculus PC (including the Oculus PC SDK);  (ii) system software for Oculus Mobile (including the Oculus Mobile  SDK);  (iii) Oculus integration with the Epic Games Unreal Engine; and (iv) Oculus integration with the Unity Technologies Unity Game Engine.”

Facebook commented on the demands by calling them “legally flawed and factually unwarranted”. As for the money, Facebook stated they’re still planning to appeal the court’s ruling in favor of ZeniMax.

Since it was also ruled by the same jury that Oculus did not misappropriate trade secrets from ZeniMax, It’s unlikely their demand to pull Oculus products from shelves will be granted. Legal expert Joshua Rich told Ars Technica, “Had they prevailed on the trade secrets claim, [ZeniMax] would have been in an extremely strong position for an injunction… Here, I think is a relatively weak argument.”

Facebook has already been struggling to get their VR tech off the ground, which hasn’t really seen high demand since its launch. Company executives say they’re working on long term plans for Oculus. Adding onto that, Facebook will have to juggle battling serious legal action.

 

From The Chatty

  • reply
    February 26, 2017 11:00 AM

    Donovan Erskine posted a new article, ZeniMax Files Injunction to Completely Stop Sales of Oculus Rift

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 11:20 AM

      as someone that owns an oculus rift man wtf

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 11:28 AM

      This is terrible considering it was ruled they didn't actually steal copyrighted materials but Palmer was guilty of violating an NDA.

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 11:52 AM

      Yeah doesn't look like this will be successful.

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 12:42 PM

      WTF is ZeniMax so pissed off about regarding this.. Were they planning on releasing their own VR headset or they just trying to take a slice of the 2B pie? I don't really understand why they are fussing over it..

      • reply
        February 26, 2017 12:45 PM

        I think theyre really mad they lost john carmack

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 10:41 PM

          Troof. When they said "You can't release Doom 3 BFG VR", that was the beginning of the end for John Carmack and Zenimax.

      • reply
        February 26, 2017 12:47 PM

        Cormack has a reputation of being pretty ruthless with his partners and colleagues, just look how many people were pushed out and cast aside in early id. Maybe he left Zenimax on really bad terms and they're opting to go after him.

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 12:47 PM

          *car fn phone

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 3:38 PM

          With Id it was setup with a ruthless outcome, but everyone agreed to it (even if it was a horrible agreement that I never would have agreed to).

          With Oculus he was so damned open about it with the public from day one, that I kind of roll my eyes at ZeniMax's response. If they bought Id for brainshare they should have done a better job of locking things down or maybe bothered reading his blog posts (and later tweets) or noticing all the times he was actively asking Zeni HR questions (another thing he was very, very open about) every now and again. I get the feeling that *somebody* was, and they figured it would be more beneficial to just sit back and see what happened.

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 8:20 PM

          I think it's extremely clear at this point that they did not part on good terms.

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 9:25 PM

          Plenty of past coworkers will apparently quite willing to work with him again at Oculus (and going all the way back to fairly early days at Id, not just current people), so that doesn't appear to be some universal truth.

          • reply
            February 26, 2017 10:43 PM

            All the documentaries out there indicate that there was truly friction, but most people report that it's fundamentally satisfying working with someone like Carmack.

      • reply
        February 26, 2017 12:48 PM

        I don't even think this would benefit them at all. It just seems really petty.

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 1:13 PM

          My biggest problem with all of this is how it hurts indie devs who are on Oculus. If the injunction happens, they get hurt the most. None of this shit really hurts Zenimax or Oculus, it is all minor and they will survive just fine, but the little guys will get shit on.

          It is definitely petty shit. I agree that shit like NDA violations and even theft are serious crimes, but penalize the people who do it, figure out the money shit, and move on. Unless the product is hurting people physically, or it is a literal verbatim copy of an existing product without the rights, then you are just trying to hurt people to settle your bullshit vendetta.

      • reply
        February 26, 2017 3:26 PM

        This is about forcing Facebook to not appeal

      • reply
        February 27, 2017 4:20 AM

        ZeniMax is created and run by lawyers.

        That should answer all your questions.

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 3:23 PM

      Ok, this is really fucking dumb. The lawsuit seemed kind of bad enough, but companies do that stuff, they have to sometimes to defend their name and fight for what is there. But after doing that and winning (at least partially) you'd think they'd be set. This is just too far.... this is getting close to me boycotting ZeniMax. I'm a huge Oculus supporter, they have done so much to push VR as thing which actually works and people want. Trying to stop Oculus is getting close to trying to stop VR in general. This really pisses me off. Was ZeniMax planning on making an affordable consumer VR headset?! NO fucking way. Then why are they pursuing this so hard?

      • reply
        February 26, 2017 5:22 PM

        They haven't gotten anything yet as oculus is appealing the decision. So increasing pressure by possibly winning this injunction they can force facebook to settle quickly and beyond the verdict amount.

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 3:37 PM

      3 Billion for Oculus, man oh man Facebook must be thinking "what.the.fuck". Heck of a bargain,.........

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 8:01 PM

      Did Carmack murder someone on the way out? There's gotta be something more than what we've seen, right?

      Or I guess maybe they've got especially scummy lawyers.

      • reply
        February 26, 2017 8:19 PM

        Zenimax/bethesda is super sleazy, word is they fucked over studios like arcane successfully with the intend to ruin them financially so they could buy them up. They apparently pulled that shit on humanhead as well but failed, though that studio was in a standoff and took a huge hit.

        Its also a litigious company that went after notch for the use of the word "scrolls" they are in for the money and scorched earth.

        Carmack on the other hand is a ruthless sociapath when it comes to business, he fucked over romero (who basically didn’t see a dime for making quake), and he and the remaining founders were at each other throat constantly and fucked over adrian carmack when they effectively pushed him out of the company to get their hands on his 40% stake in the company (so they could make a killing when they sold to zenimax. Word is they underpoaid him for a sum around 30-40 millions).

        He went to court. The details of the settlement did not emerge but lets say he owns a 5 star hotel and golf course in ireland now.

        Tl;dr zenimax is the worst but carmack is a notorious asshole who got away with shit his whole life (its a red thread in his biography, from being a hyperintelligent deliquent to dumpsterdiving tech thief).
        Its well established that luckey palmer is a piece of shit and so there isnt really anyone to root for in this clusterfuck (facebook and zuckerberg are probably worse).

        Vr takes aj hit

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 8:40 PM

          If I'm reading this right, everyone involved in this mess is pretty much fucking terrible.

          • reply
            February 26, 2017 8:52 PM

            There is probably a spectrum of awfulness and you have to see it in context to whom it effects (consumers) but yeah nobody looks good in this. Also we'll done parsing through that post, it's barely coherent (just woke up. First coffee coming up). For what it's worth, unlike zenimax Carmack has done shit tons of good for the industry, and has always been releasing source code for his engines, held tech talks where he was very candid about his work, posted plan files in the old days, was easily approachable etc. Without him fighting for open-source tons of games would not have happened.

            This site wouldn't exist without him shipping an unreleased gl port of quake to the shacks founder.

        • reply
          February 26, 2017 10:33 PM

          Before Romero and Adrian Carmack there was Tom Hall.

          • reply
            February 26, 2017 10:45 PM

            Tom Hall is basically the only person that comes off as a really good guy after reading Masters of Doom although it seems like Romero is a pretty cool dude now that he's had time to chill out and kinda just do smaller projects and teach.

            • reply
              February 26, 2017 10:48 PM

              I keep wishing he'd end up with the Commander Keen license somehow. Shame Worlds of Wander fizzled

              • reply
                February 26, 2017 10:57 PM

                Also WTF he voiced Walton Simons. I did not know that. As a fan of Deus Ex and Tom Hall I must hide my head in shame

            • reply
              February 27, 2017 4:33 AM

              you forget Sandy Petersen

              • reply
                February 27, 2017 11:20 AM

                Oops, yeah, Sandy is cool too and the "You're a Mormon?!" story with Romero is one of my favorite stories in the book.

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 8:34 PM

      Oh no, dozens of potential sales will be affected

    • reply
      February 26, 2017 10:53 PM

      #HL3VRCONFIRMED

    • reply
      February 27, 2017 1:20 PM

      Most corporate lawsuits aren't about benefiting the plaintiff, they're more about damaging the defendant for petty personal reasons.