Madden NFL 17 Review: Many Given Sundays

Madden NFL 17 is still the gridiron you remember, but with some smart improvements that capture the drama of the real thing. Our review.


The Madden NFL series poses a challenge. What meaningful statements, if any, can be made about a series now in its 28th iteration with no real competition that simulates a sport that has remained relatively consistent for decades? It feels like one of the many constants in the annals of the NFL: the Cowboys will continue to be a spiteful monument to man’s hubris, we will always question whether Joe Flacco is elite, and Madden is the only game in town. But there’s something else that I thought about as I was playing Madden NFL 17–the intersection of sports games and story.

A League of Your Own

See, in many ways Madden is a microcosm of the NFL itself. The league will tell you football is a game of excitement and passion where anything can happen on any given Sunday. In reality, much of football is built around cautious management of a manicured public image with little to no room for expression outside (or inside) the lines, and the electronic version of the real thing does not differ.

Yet the narratives and mythology that grow around the real game become bigger than its mundane commercial reality, and Madden explores this in its own way in the Franchise mode. This year, EA offers an optional new “Play the Moments” mode where you can fast-forward through most of the game to get to the hero moments–major stops on third down, red zone scoring opportunities, blocking last-second field goals–that make football exciting and also keep your league games bite-size while still affording significant control over the outcome. A Franchise game can be finished in about 20 minutes with this option turned on, meaning busy players could knock out a playoff run on their lunch break–a feature I appreciate more than maybe anything else EA has ever added to the franchise.

Combined with the returning XP system that allows players to be leveled up and improved over the course of a season, it is very easy to craft stories around these experiences and connections with particular players. Even though my championship run with the Packers saw star quarterback Aaron Rodgers knocked out with a dislocated elbow in the NFC title game, his season-long connections with receiver Jordy Nelson over the course of the season helped Nelson turn my backup quarterback into a Super Bowl winner. Feeling like my choices during the course of a Franchise season mattered and added to the legend of the 2017 Super Bowl champs gave me some of the same thrills of a lengthy RPG in a fraction of the time.

Rush n' Attack

Helping to craft the on-field story this year are new gameplay changes that lead to a more balanced game. Traditionally, Madden has been heavily weighted toward passing offenses. Last year offered the intriguing idea of different catch styles for different scenarios but ended up making the risky Aggressive catches all but unstoppable. This year, Aggressive catches are more likely to result in tipped balls and turnovers as intended, and the running game has been upgraded with new Precision and Speed moves that give more options for getting around defenders. While not always perfect and heavily reliant on timing these moves make a run offense much more viable.

EA was smart enough to make some long-needed changes at the special teams level of the game as well. I nearly clapped when I saw this year’s version introduced a much more standard three-click swing meter for all punts, kicks, and field goals. Not only does this replace the loathsome analog kick meter from previous years but it also makes field goals and punts a much surer strategic bet. Thanks to the precision of the new meter I was able to win some games I would have otherwise lost. There’s definitely more to keep track of on both sides of the ball than ever before, but this year’s Madden also provides constant prompts and tooltips to keep the more memory-challenged of us aware of all possible moves and options. Even with some occasionally wonky collision detection and player physics, the game feels more balanced and accessible than it has in a while.

Keeping It In-Bounds

Draft Champions was arguably my favorite addition to last year’s Madden and frankly a mode that should be standard for all sports games going forward. This year, in addition to the standard mode, Draft Champions makes its Hearthstone inspiration official by offering a special Ranked mode. Ranked mode requires entry tickets that can be cashed in for a shot at bigger prizes than the standard modes. (Naturally, you can give EA money to get more tickets if you are so inclined.) While the thrill of potentially gambling real money on your Madden skills to get you to the promised land of better Ultimate Team packs is probably appealing to some, I struggled to find significant success in this mode and I shuddered at the idea of throwing actual money at the game only to be fed into the online meat grinder. If only I could blame my misery on net code, but I can’t–the rounds I played were largely flawless, with only a couple instances of lag.

Finally, the most important part of any story is the presentation, and here is where EA’s focus on iteration over outright improvement becomes most apparent. For every clever tweak like regular downloadable commentary updates and new broadcast graphics and angles, there are legacy problems like lengthy load times, animation glitches and questionable sideline models. The dead-eyed low-poly Jim Caldwell model uniquely captures his sense of depressed futility but looks jarring next to the shiny helmets and dynamic jersey dirt on the field. This far into the console life cycle it’s harder to justify such disparity. It’s also worth noting that I experienced a few lockups that required a restart when selecting menu options, though the vast majority of the game ran smoothly.

Take a Knee

Of course, all stories need an ending. To the point, Madden NFL 17 is a quality Madden game. It does a lot of things right, and fixes most of the major shortcomings of previous editions. If you’ve lapsed in the series or just want to know if you should grab this year’s game, go forward knowing that you will get a lot of mileage from it. It’s good. At the same time, however, it is still absolutely a Madden game, and in the 12th year of EA’s exclusivity deal with the NFL it’s hard not to pine for a little competition. Sunrise, sunset.

This review is based on a Xbox One download code provided by the publisher. Madden NFL 17 will be available in retail and digital stores on August 23, for $59.99. The game is rated E.

Review for
Madden NFL 17
  • Franchise mode is faster and more accessible
  • Gameplay tweaks make for more accessible and varied offensive plans
  • Draft Champions is still great fun
  • Downloadable commentary updates are brilliant
  • Online play is rock solid
  • Still some legacy issues
  • Graphical disparity between sidelines and on-field
  • Load times can be annoying
From The Chatty
  • reply
    August 22, 2016 9:00 AM

    Bryan Carr posted a new article, Madden NFL 17 Review: Many Given Sundays

    • reply
      August 22, 2016 9:09 AM


      • reply
        August 22, 2016 9:21 AM

        I wish I could have skipped last year. This sounds like an improvement.

      • reply
        August 22, 2016 10:14 AM

        I am tempted because I skipped last year. I don't want Gronk in my game collection though.

      • reply
        August 22, 2016 10:23 AM

        I wish I could get it for $30-40 without waiting until the end of the season. It has some nice improvements most years but not really $60 worth (which isn't even a knock on the devs, most $60 games have way more than 1 year of dev work in them).

      • reply
        August 22, 2016 6:25 PM

        Same. First year I've done that (not finish even one season) and first year I'll do the same (skipping).

    • reply
      August 22, 2016 9:41 AM

      Who is Bryan Carr?

    • reply
      August 22, 2016 4:22 PM

      props for the Rush n' Attack reference

      • reply
        August 22, 2016 6:40 PM

        Was that game title supposed to be a play on "Russian attack"? As a kid I always thought it was Russian attack instead of rush n

        • reply
          August 22, 2016 7:01 PM

          ya. and its probably why all the bad guys are wearing red clothing.

    • reply
      August 22, 2016 6:00 PM

      Last year when I visited my sister I played some Madden on her Xbox. Not even an Xbone, a 360. First Madden game I'd played since the last PC version which was something like Madden 2004.

      It's wtf-complicated now. Could not even figure out the management mode. Is it just super complex, a bad interface, or am I just realold now?

      • reply
        August 22, 2016 6:27 PM

        football is an insanely complicated game and Madden gets closer and closer to modeling it accurately every year

    • reply
      August 22, 2016 6:24 PM

      This comment from the IGN review is great:

      IGN quotes about past Madden games...

      Madden 17 -- "...a return to form."
      Madden 16 -- "Game Changer"
      Madden 15 -- "...feels like a mostly fresh start for the series."
      Madden 14/25 -- To be fair here, IGN wasn't thrilled with it
      Madden 13 -- "Football is fun again."

      I'm not so much bashing IGN for being inconsistent (i.e., every year is a redefining year for the franchise) as much as I'm irritated that EA has a stranglehold over the NFL license and continues to take it for granted to the point where every year needs to be a redefining year that will bring the series back from the doldrums.

    • reply
      August 22, 2016 7:03 PM

      Madden sucks. Gimme NCAA back you bastards.

      • reply
        August 22, 2016 7:24 PM


        • reply
          August 22, 2016 7:55 PM

          There's a hilarious story I read years ago about the reaction of the NCAA's lawyers when they - completely ignorant of videogames - found out that not only was there a game with the players' likeness being sold, but there were many millions of them, to which the players got $0. And they were still selling it. Like, right that moment.

          It was one pf those moments where the things said about your client behind the curtain cannot be put in simple english, lol.

    • reply
      August 22, 2016 7:08 PM

      I couldn't play last years because of the horrid post play lag. Once the play was over you didn't get your play call menu for what felt like 10 seconds. Just killed the pace. Whole game felt unpolished and favored glamor over gameplay. I mean it looked like a real game watching the players slowly get up and interact but once you saw it twice and just wanted good gameplay it was unbelievably frustrating and mind boggling how the game shipped like that. How is the speed of the menus and play calling compared to last year?

Hello, Meet Lola