Report: GameSpot's Gerstmann Fired Due to Negative Kane & Lynch Review

Rumors have been swirling today that Jeff Gerstmann, executive editor at CNET-owned major video game site GameSpot, was fired after giving a generally unimpressed review of Io Interactive's Kane & Lynch: Dead Men. Gerstmann awarded the game a 6.0. [Edit: Gerstmann had particularly negative words in his video review, which was removed from the site by GameSpot today.] (Though Shacknews does not score its reviews, our own Kane & Lynch review was similar in its verdict.)

According to the reports, the layoff came after Kane & Lynch publisher Eidos took issue with the review and threatened to pull its considerable ad contract. GameSpot's front page is currently almost entirely re-skinned with Kane & Lynch imagery.

The rumor began bouncing around various industry circles over the past day, and this evening was reported by Kotaku. Popular webcomic Penny Arcade posted a strip about the alleged incident tonight, outside of its normal publishing schedule.

Shacknews can confidently confirm via its own sources that Gerstmann was indeed fired yesterday from his position at GameSpot. The source declined to comment as to whether the firing was directly related to the reported Eidos situation, but the circumstances are suspicious at the least.

Gerstmann had been an employee at GameSpot for about a decade, and took the place of former executive editor Greg Kasavin when Kasavin left the company to work for Electronic Arts as a producer.

Update: CNET employee Tim Tracy has posted what appears to be a farewell notice on his GameSpot blog. Until July, Tracy was an editor at GameSpot, and since then has been working for CNET-owned If indeed Tracy is departing, it is unknown if it is related to Gerstmann's dismissal.

Filed Under
From The Chatty
  • reply
    November 29, 2007 7:16 PM

    Bwahahaha. What a hilarious clusterfuck. Nice one there Eidos. Flex some of your muscle to promote a shitty game.

    • reply
      November 29, 2007 7:20 PM

      What was the last truely great game that Eidos published?

      • reply
        November 29, 2007 7:21 PM

        Tomb Raider Legend was pretty awesome.

      • reply
        November 29, 2007 7:23 PM

        Great? Its been a while. Tomb Raider Legend and Anniversary were good, I had fun playing with them. But they lack a lot of polish to be great. TR8 is supposed to be current gen consoles only so Im interested to see what they come up with.

    • reply
      November 29, 2007 7:27 PM


Hello, Meet Lola