Mass Effect SeXbox Critic Corrects Statements, Expresses Regret
by Chris Faylor, Jan 26, 2008 1:05pm PSTCooper Lawrence (pictured left), who recently appeared on Fox News' The Live Desk with Martha MacCallum and, despite never having actually played the game, attacked BioWare's Mass Effect (X360) for containing pornography and misrepresenting women, has now admitted that she was wrong in her criticism.
"I recognize that I misspoke," Lawrence, the author of several self-help books, told The New York Times. "Before the show I had asked somebody about what they had heard, and they had said it's like pornography.
"I really regret saying that, and now that I've seen the game and seen the sex scenes it's kind of a joke," she continued. "I've seen episodes of [the ABC television show] Lost that are more sexually explicit."
During the segment, which repeatedly and incorrectly informed viewers that the game contained full digital nudity and graphic sex, Lawrence was asked by games journalist Geoff Keighley if she had ever played the game. She laughed and answered, "No."
BioWare and its owner Electronic Arts, meanwhile, are not amused by the situation.
"We're hurt," said BioWare CEO Ray Muzyka, who noted the studio's belief in video games as an art form. "On behalf of the 120 people who poured their blood and tears into this game over three years, we're just really hurt that someone would misrepresent the game without even playing it. All we can hope for is that people who actually play our games will see the truth."
In a letter, Electronic Arts labeled the Fox News segment as "a new level of recklessness" and demanded th Fox News correct its errors. Fox News then invited the company to appear on-air and set the record straight, though EA has yet to determine if it will accept the invitation.
The gaming public pursued its own form of vigilante justice in response, initiating a smear campaign on Lawrence's latest book, The Cult of Perfection: Making Peace With Your Inner Overachiever. Online retailers that allow user-submitted reviews, such as Amazon.com and Barnes & Nobel, were inundated with false and extremely negative reviews, many of which gave the book the lowest possible rating and have now been removed.
The accompanying text often highlighted the fact that users had not actually read the book, instead basing their judgment on unsubstantiated rumors--much like Lawrence had done with Mass Effect.
Twisted Metal promotion blows up Sweet Tooth's truck
Demon's Souls 'underestimated' by Sony
Shack PSA: Skyrim PS3 players should create new manual save
Star Trek to be co-published by Namco Bandai in 2013
MobyGames Classic: Syndicate community stories
Report: Unreal Engine 4 to be revealed in 2012
Frictional teasing new Amnesia
Weekend Confirmed 99 - Double Fine, Reckoning, Cell HD: emergence
Indie Royale's V-Day bundle launches







Comments
I don't like FOX News at all, but that's an entirely separate issue. What we have here is someone who is supposed to be part of the media, part of a conglomerate from which we receive news and (hopefully) facts about situations. Whether those situations involve video games, an officer getting gunned down, a local man closing his shop which has been in operation for decades, a review of a product, or a terrorist bombing, the information should be presented with facts, and conjecture should be labeled as such.
This woman labeled certain portions of Mass Effect as facts, and they were not. Calling Mass Effect's barely visible sex scene pornography wasn't even conjecture; it just wasn't true, period. For a member of the media to attack anything with what he or she purports to be facts, and for those alleged facts to be not even conjecture but unfounded opinion, is the lowest form of reporting.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 23 replies.
I think at this point the fight between the author and the industry is even and it's time to move on...
To Fox News. Fair and balanced my ass.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 47 replies.
She was invited on the show to talk about the psychology of sex and violence in gaming (taking an unpopular stance, I know). She was misinformed about the content of the game; it is unreasonable to obligate her to play a 30-hour game in order to participate in the segment. She is not a journalist. In that regard, Geoff Keighley's question to her was unfair. Her incredulous response was reasonable.
Let's be clear: the question WAS fair and even IMPORTANT to direct at the host and/or segment producer. A certain level of criticism directed at these parties is absolutely justifiable. Unfortunately, Keighley didn't ask those people (although I still think he aquitted himself and the game nicely).
Despite all this, Lawrence was the first to come out and publicly express regret at her role in the incident, to the point of ridiculing the idea that Mass Effect's content was explicit. Taking this all into account, the character attacks and spamming of her book reviews were low class. A certain gaming website, in light of the snide posture they've taken, would do well to publicly rebuke these practices, in some fashion.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 3 replies.
I watch it to see what kind of attacks they will have on the Clintons, or talk about how evil arabs are.
It's like the Daily Show...except they are not trying to be funny.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 11 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 6 replies.
Whaddya expect? "News"?
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 8 replies.
Boohoo. We got free publicity for our game.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 4 replies.
And of course gamers have put themselves on the same level as Ms. Lawrence by flooding sites with fake reviews and bogus scores for her book. Awesome job guys! Way to show everyone that "gamer justice." *rolls eyes*
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 37 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 7 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 4 replies.
It seems she was brought on as an 'expert' on child psychology, and not knowing much about the game she was meant to be discussing, assumed that Fox had got their facts straight, and went with the assumption that the game did have pornographic material. Now obviously she should have done more research before appearing on the program, but at the same time, she was called out as an expert on her specific field, not on video games, and had Fox actually done their job, she would have been able to provide a fair commentary.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 4 replies.
Ms. Lawrence has given her apology - whatever motivations she had for doing so are inconsequential. She didn't have to admit she was wrong, but she did, she did so publicly and unambiguously. I for one commend her for this move. It shows a lot of class, something that is woefully lacking in a lot of modern journalism.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 18 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 3 replies.
I hope this shit doesn't affect future releases and won't result in a step even further back regarding in-game nudity overall in gaming, with devs having the fear in mind that they will get burned by the media.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 4 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
You guys must have missed the time fox news reported that the california wild fires were started by al qaeda.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 3 replies.
Step 2: at what point was damage done and does slander or gross misrepresentation come into play? People need to be slapped around for this, so that things like this don't happen, or so that they are at least fair and educated debates.
You guys blaming FOX should realize that this could just as easily happen elsewhere. Ignorance on the part of the panel, the reporter doing the interview all led to this. The reporter could have said something like "But come on, I've seen these scenes and they are PG13 or slightly above and the game is rated for 17+ - is there really an issue here?" and let the two sides debate it, but at least KNOW WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT and pitch honest questions that make BOTH sides justify their arguments.
It's all pretty ridiculous and people should be accountable.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 10 replies.
I'm tired of the media, liberal, conservative, Xenu.... fuck em in the purple donkey asshole.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 6 replies.
fox & company to go.
start with miss martha macullum
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
I would've commended her had she done it the following day of the broadcast but this just speaks of a quick and dirty bit of damage control. I hope she goes bankrupt.
Or you could just be a good reporter.
Isn't this thing hyped enough without mis-worded headlines?
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 5 replies.