Microsoft Defends 'Peddling Add-ons' Strategy

46
Following Sony's claim that the Xbox 360 is merely "peddling add-ons" to keep up with the PlayStation 3, Xbox maker Microsoft has fired back, asserting the merits of encouraging consumer choice instead of forcing components buyers may not need.

"Our strategy from the beginning was to have multiple SKUs with a very flexible offering so the customer can choose the experience that they want," Xbox 360 group PR manager David Dennis explained to Edge. "If you don't need a hard drive, you're not forced to have one. If you don't need Wi-Fi, you're not forced to pay for one."

Yesterday, sales-tracking group NPD revealed that the PlayStation 3 had sold 3.69 million units in the United States during 2008, while the Xbox 360 sold 4.74 million. Lifetime sales figures show that the Xbox 360 has more than doubled the PS3's total U.S. sales, with the Xbox 360 at 13.89 million and the PS3 at 6.94 million.

"The strategy of having a console that is $200 more expensive that has features that people don't potentially need or want but have to pay for--looking at [Sony's] sales numbers--I'd say it's probably not the winning strategy at this point, especially given the current economic situation," Dennis added.

Currently, the Xbox 360 is available in three different models: the $199 Arcade, which lacks a hard drive, the $299 Pro with a 60GB hard drive, and the $399 120GB Elite. All three versions require a separate add-on for wireless internet functionality.

Meanwhile, Sony sells two models of the PlayStation 3, both with built-in wireless internet capabilities: the $399 80GB unit, and a $499 160GB model that also contains a copy of Naughty Dog's action-adventure game Uncharted: Drake's Fortune.

Along with the price differences, one other key advantage Microsoft had over Sony was time: the Xbox 360 launched in 2005, while the PlayStation 3 arrived in 2006.

Chris Faylor was previously a games journalist creating content at Shacknews.

From The Chatty
  • reply
    January 16, 2009 2:21 PM

    The fuck. Xbox 360 NEEDS a harddrive. The arcade was an excuse to make people fork over 100 dollars for something that's actually worth 20-30.

    • reply
      January 16, 2009 2:30 PM

      no, you need a harddrive. one of my best friends bought a 360 Arcade, and he never goes on Live. All he does is buy games and play them. He doesn't want live, he doesn't care for DLC. And get this, he's not a hardcore gamer.

      • reply
        January 16, 2009 4:45 PM

        ok yeah, I agree about the HDD, that should have been standard from the start.

    • reply
      January 16, 2009 2:39 PM

      No, since they put in a faster HDD and tons of RAM (PS3 only has half the amount of system memory and BR transfer rates suck compared to a 12X DVD), the 360 could get away with not needing a HDD. Where as the PS3 needs one to install games so it doesn't have to rely on streaming from the disc alone.

      Some 360 games require a HDD but those number what, less than the number of fingers on my hand?

      Also, the point of the Core/Arcade is to make the entry price affordable as well as to add value to the Pro/Premium/Elite feel like a better value.

      When you see that a 360 can sell for $200, you already feel that is a cheap price. But since you don't want to waste money on one HDD and other accessories included in the Premium, you buy that instead.

      A similar technique has worked well for retailers especially Walmart. Where you walk in and see in the middle of the aisle a microwave for $20. You will then be lead to think that microwaves at Walmart are cheap so you go buy the $50 you really wanted with the features you need. The low price point of the same product is there get to you buy it.

    • reply
      January 16, 2009 2:51 PM

      You know, I would have agreed with you, but I recently bought a 512MB memory card for my 360 (at a ridiculous price). I'm surprised how many saved games it can hold, and I could see how someone on a budget could get by without a hard drive.

    • reply
      January 16, 2009 2:54 PM

      I know people that would never, ever go online with their console but would still enjoy playing the games on the system. The $200 Arcade model is a superb offering for those types.

    • reply
      January 16, 2009 2:59 PM

      you can get the 20 gig hardrive plus 3 months xbox live subcription for $30. Not a bad deal

      • reply
        January 16, 2009 4:28 PM

        doesn't work if you have Jasper and the newer integrated memory units

    • reply
      January 16, 2009 3:04 PM

      You can play games via Xbox Live without buying a harddrive. Did it myself when I got a new Xbox 360 and GTA 4, used the memory stick of course.

      So for someone that doesn't play demo's or download arcade games and extra content- you can get away with just a memory stick.

    • reply
      January 16, 2009 5:51 PM

      Having one sku not have a harddrive effects developer decisions. If all the 360's shipped with a harddrive the games would be better because developers could rely on it.

Hello, Meet Lola