Evening Reading

Thread Truncated. Click to see all 94 replies.

• toggle

  super mario galaxy, portal, tf2 : feek
  • ^ + HL2:Ep2 to round out the Box : skankcore
• toggle

  1. Portal. 2. S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 3. HL2:E2. : thewriter
  • toggle

    In fact, Crysis probably beats HL2:E2 off the third place spot but I can't run it. : thewriter
    • toggle

      I loved EP2 but it was definitely "more of the same" whereas Crysis was all kinds of new shit. Awesome ga... : oatmela
      • Sure. I liked what I played of it, but I had to shelve until such times as more than one game is demandin... : thewriter
• toggle

  surprised Witcher's not higher up : RikiTiki2
  • toggle

    Loading :( : Mondo
    • It doesn't take that long for it to load on my system. It does take a while to save. :[ : CrustaR
  • toggle

    is The witcher on PC? : oatmela
    • toggle

      Yes and a good PC rpg : Mondo
      • toggle

        hmm, I thought it was a console game. I will have to check it out for sure. I have heard a lot of good th... : oatmela
        • toggle

          PC only, oatmela. : CrustaR
          • :( I thought Crysis was the only game to have the balls to release on PC only. I'll definitely check it o... : oatmela
    • I think the real question is, Is The Witcher NOT on the pc? : famine101
• peggle extreme : infiltrator`
• i think each of those should win in their own category: Best 3d puzzle game, Best FPS action game, Best '... : gyokuro
• i'm gonna pull a time magazine and say 2007 in general is GOTY : shavenewok
• toggle

  1. Portal 2. Peggle Bioshock 3. EP2 I'm going to guess Crysis is going to throw EP2 off that list if... : devi| dog
  • After cheating off everyone else, I forgot to put TF2 as #1, I just group that in a different category fo... : devi| dog
• I only bought two games this year. Bioshock and Halo 3. I enjoyed them both quite a bit. : sleepytea
• toggle

  Mass Effect : locater16
  • As much as I want Mass Effect to be GOTY... it ain't. Here's hoping for ME2 though. : Jonathan
• toggle

  I propose that the Shack NOT do GotY awards this year. Who's with me!?!?! : PenicillinX57
  • No pictures of new games either! : devi| dog
• Halo 3 (but probably Mario if I had it), Skate, Portal. : paravis
• 1. Bioshock & Portal 2. TF2 : AMikaboshi
• CoD4 : maulla
• Mario Galaxy Team Fortress 2 Zak and Wiki : Grumbeld
• TF2 or Portal. : Rigor Morts
• toggle

  Super Mario Galaxy, Orange Box, Bioshock : TastyWheat
  • That'd be my top 3. I'd have to finish Mass Effect but I think ME would be 4. : kainen1
• #1327

  Refresh Thread

  By: Serpico74 x Show Full Post

  Reply

  Super Mario Galaxy by a huge margin, then Orange Box (Portal just barely beating TF2, then Episode 2 if I had to pick an order within that).

  Dec 04, 2007 8:53pm PST
  Super Mario Galaxy by a huge margin, then Orange Box (Portal just barely beating TF2, then Episode 2 if I... : Serpico74
• Too many good games, but if I have to narrow it down it would be. 1. BioShock 2. Super Mario Galaxy ... : manlyman
• TF2 : edgewise
• in no particular order: STALKER, Mass Effect, Crysis : kill9
• toggle

  Crysis for SP, TF2 for MP : spectr3
  • toggle

    I'm thinking this is a good answer, though I haven't actually played Crysis yet. Don't be afraid to nomin... : SockMonkeh
    • I'll admit the Witcher is pretty fun, but the loading times got to me and I'm on an extended break for no... : spectr3
• Shouldn't it be GOTY other than Orange Box because it so obviously wins that we are really just playing f... : rosewood
• 1. Mario Galaxy 2. Portal 3. This is where it gets impossible : cdbeckman
• 1. Witcher 2. TF2 3. Portal 4. Bioshock. : hirez
• TF2!!!!! : anthonybean
• Forza2 Heavenly Sword Half-life 2 : trevis
• I won't be able to play Crysis 'til Thursday so I'll let you know then. : SockMonkeh
• TF2 : aeg1x
• 1. Metroid Prime 3 2. Super Mario Galaxy 3. Portal : MoreVespeneGas
• TF2 - It owns me body, mind, and soul. : ChibiJosh
• Portal, it was the most original and creative idea I've played in the last few years. I don't have a s... : qwpeoriu
• toggle

  The Witcher, Mario Galaxy, Mass Effect : FushigiDenki
  • oh, and TF2 :) : FushigiDenki
• Burning Crusade! Not a whole lot of people have brought it up in this thread, but I've heard HL2ep2 a ... : invisible_kid
• toggle

  So far I'd say: 1. Portal 2. Mario Galaxy 3. Forza 2 : zakazi
  • crap TF2/Portal is more like it. Much love for TF2. : zakazi
• portal, tf2, mario galaxy, and metroid prime 3 are all fighting each other at the top of my list : Mr.SEX
• toggle

  Can't order them, and really I could pick a lot more games but here's what I'm tossing in: Rock Band, ... : Begawkiness
  • Oh yeah Halo 3 was really good too heh : Begawkiness
• S.T.A.L.K.E.R. , TF2, then Bioshock : hobbespanache
• 1.S.T.A.L.K.E.R 2.Portal 3.NWN2:MoB : duncandun
• Crysis/Bioshock : glio1337
• toggle

  Overall: The Orange Box Xbox 360: Assassin's Creed PS3: Heavenly Sword PC: Orange Box : Magus
  • toggle

    I'll go ahead and give you an obligatory cry post about how Orange Box doesn't count as a GOTY. : the city
    • toggle

      I'm pleasantly surprised that the number of people who defy simple logic and insist Orange Box is one gam... : spectr3
      • toggle

        GO SPECTR3 GO http://www.sapiens.staticservers.com/pics/misc/BeatDeadHorse.gif : Sapiens
        • I'm going to unabashedly keep pulverizing that horse. Screw all who oppose me. : spectr3
• 1. cod4 2. Portal 3. Crysis : cheesefubar
• If Time can name more than one person POTY then these three games should be GOTY: Mass Effect Orange Bo... : Sailor of Fortune
• 1. The Witcher 2. Mass Effect 3. God of War 2 : Ravenkettle
• 1. Bioshock 2. Mass Effect 3. Portal : lookitzpancakes
• 1) Bioshock 2) TF2 3) Pac Man Championship Edition : Jayx77
• Mario Galaxy > everything else. : Drewus
• 1: god of war 2 2: bioshock 3: assassins creed : CoRDS
• (1) CoD4 (2) Portal (3) FIFA08 (yes, I like it) : Albemuth
• Portal, TF2, and HL2:E2. Crysis comes a close fourth. Have not purchased COD4. : WaterSign
• 1. Metroid Prime 3 2. Team Fortress 2 3. Portal 4. HL2:Ep2 I haven't played that many new games thi... : K1Bond007
• WOW:BC :\ it's true : mwasher
• 1) TF2. 2) Portal. 3) The Burning Crusade. : Bamii
• TF2, CoD4, all PC : ElPopo
• RTS GOTY World in Conflict : thewindcriesmary
• - Metroid Prime 3 - Crysis - HL2 : Ep2 : moshman
• toggle

  1. Bioshock 2. COD4 : klearlyunseen
  • 3. Mass Effect : klearlyunseen
• 1. Portal / Orange Box 2. BioShock or Mass Effect 3. Guitar Hero 2 (x360) : chazums
• STALKER > Crysis > The Witcher > Orange Box > Mask of the Betrayer > Bioshock Bioshock disappointed me f... : Autocrawler
• toggle

  1. TF2 - I haven't a game this much since WoW and Quake 2. Portal - for the funny and for the ending son... : mrwolf710
  • haven't *played* a game this much...dammit. : mrwolf710
• 1. Super Mario Galaxy 2. Portal : enyakk
• I guess TF2, for the scalability, fun factor and replayability. : Nitrium
• I'll go Mass Effect and Call of Duty 4...I refuse to choose between them. : Vincent Grayson
• 1. Bioshock 2. Peggle 3. Orange Box 4. Elite Beat Agents (yeah its a game from last year I didn't play... : baron calamity
• 1. TF2 2. Crysis 3. Bioshock 4. LotRO 5. CoD4 6. Portal 7. Ep2 8. Witcher 9. Peggle : spectr3
• Mass Effect, Puzzle Quest, Portal : razorblade79
• oh please don't vote for portal, yes it's a good idea, but let it win mod of the year, Crysis is the winn... : shack_konto