Chatty Q&A: Supergiant Games discusses the making of Transistor

After playing through Supergiant's latest, Shacknews' enthusiastic community of Chatty posters had some questions for the Transistor creators. Creative director and game writer Greg Kasavin was happy to comply and provide some valuable answers.

5

It's hard to follow up a truly memorable RPG experience like Bastion. However, Supergiant Games has managed to capably do so with their sophomore effort, Transistor, creating an engaging narrative, standout characters, and a dazzling world.

After playing through Supergiant's latest, Shacknews' enthusiastic community of Chatty posters had some questions for the Transistor creators. Creative director and game writer Greg Kasavin was happy to comply and provide some valuable answers, discussing the making of their game, working as a small developer, new concepts like the Oculus Rift, and whether they'd consider revisiting the worlds of Transistor or Bastion in the future.

Nerdsbeware asks: What or why was the decision made to have a "narrator" tell the story? Was it strictly a story choice or a design choice?

Greg Kasavin: We think narrative can be one of several methods for engaging players quickly and leaving a strong impression once the game is over. We're very interested in exploring different narrative techniques in our games and taking advantage of the properties of the medium. To that end, we've found that voiceover can be good for giving context to the player's actions at the player's own pace, while at the same time making the experience feel personal or even intimate. In that sense, using voiceover extensively in Transistor was both a story choice and a design choice. We wanted players to feel like they were travelling with these characters and looking through a window into this world, rather than being told a story in the traditional sense.

BlackCat9 asks: What were your ideas and influences for creating the world of Transistor, and how did you expect players to feel when they begin to explore it?

Kasavin: It is difficult to pin down a specific set of influences, since there are so many from multiple media, and our influences are specific to each of the disciplines that form the game -- from the art and audio to the gameplay to the writing and so on. When beginning a project we tend to think a lot about the overall tone of the experience, what we want the feel of the game to be. In Transistor, we decided early on to pursue this idea of a vintage-futuristic setting, with what we called an 'operatic' tone for all that implies. I think we wanted players to experience the grandeur of the setting and the intensity of the personal stakes of the characters, while enjoying the mysteries of the gameplay -- having access to this all-powerful weapon with seemingly limitless capability. Broadly speaking, after having made this weird fantasy-frontier world in Bastion, we wanted to see what we could do in the science-fiction genre this time around.

SolrFlare asks: What lessons did you take from Bastion's development and apply to the development of Transistor?

Kasavin: Although I would never downplay the effort that went into making Bastion, we were very fortunate to have a relatively smooth development process on that game, all things considered. Since the game ended up being both critically and commercially successful, it really validated our particular approach to game development, and we wanted to approach our second game from a similar mindset: Make something new that our team was excited about, playing to the strengths of the individuals on the team.

We did not approach Transistor from the perspective of trying to fix anything about Bastion. We were more interested in making a new game with its own distinct identity. As a result, nothing about Transistor was a foregone conclusion, and even when we arrived at similar decisions to ones we made on Bastion (such as the camera angle), it was because we felt it was right for this new game.

brickmatt asks: I'm fascinated that you've used essentially the same crew to make a similar, but also totally different game. Do you try and come up with roles for everyone, and that steers the design? Or do you come up with the design, and see what roles folks could play?

Kasavin: Our goal after finishing Bastion was for the seven members of our team to stick together and make something new, and that's what we ended up doing with Transistor -- adding several key new members to the team along the way, so we're at 12 people now. For sure our games are configured around the strengths of the people we have on the team. A good example in Transistor's case is the significant role of the music in the game. Darren Korb, our audio director, is a musician by background, and having worked together successfully with his friend and vocalist, Ashley Barrett, on our first game, he was interested in doing something more with songs and music for this next project. We took that into account when formulating the fiction, and so forth. While we try to think big, we also try to work within our means, and make games we think we can make well.

pyide asks: How much thought and work went into the ability system? The sheer number of combinations, and how anything can be used as the active skill, modifiers, or passives?

Kasavin: The ability system in Transistor came together after lots of iteration, as we wanted to create an interesting and deep system to extend the moment-to-moment play experience across the full duration of the game. While we tried a lot of things there, the idea we eventually pursued was the one we felt would take the most work to get right -- but it was the most exciting idea to us! A goal of the system was to reward experimentation without forcing it. At the same time, we wanted to deliver on the idea that you've got this mysterious and powerful weapon, and provide an open-ended system that aligned with that. It was a lot of fun creating and playing with all the different permutations of abilities that we could think of, and watching different players use it in some wildly different ways.

pyide asks: Love the kind of combat experimentation the whole system fosters, really want to see more games do that sort of thing. Was it planned from the start? How long did it take to get there? Was there any specific function a team member really wanted that didn't make the final cut?

Kasavin: The specifics of our combat system were not there from the beginning, but for sure the underlying spirit of it was a guiding principle throughout development. We wanted Transistor to be a thoughtful-feeling game that let players dictate the flow of battle, and captured some of the drama and suspense inherent to some of our favorite classic turn-based games and tactical RPGs. It took a good couple of years of iteration and development to arrive at the eventual system. We prototyped dozens of different abilities, many of which were very cool, and I think in the end found their way into the game as part of some of the power combinations.

snot3353 asks: How do you manage to produce such incredible art and audio with such a small team in a respectable amount of time? Do you outsource any of it?

Kasavin: All our visuals are done in-house by Jen Zee our art director, Camilo Vanegas our 3D modeler/animator, and Josh Barnett our UI and visual FX artist. We worked with a team called Earbash to create many of the sound effects in the game, though other than that, all the audio and voice recording was done by Darren Korb. The work these folks produced was tremendously motivating -- I think we all strive to do our part to live up to what everyone else on team is doing. When you're doing what you love, I think you can accomplish a lot with relatively limited means.

SolrFlare asks: Is there anything more you would have liked to add if you had more time?

Kasavin: We built Transistor on our own time and budget, and we would not have released it if we felt it was somehow incomplete. So no, there was nothing that we cut that we didn't think was better off being cut. We cut stuff constantly throughout development in the interest of leaving behind only the best stuff for the finished work.

Wombat Woo asks: Have you looked into new technology like Oculus Rift at all? What's your take on some of the overhead demos of Unreal Engine 4 running on Oculus Rift and do you feel like it could be applied to one of your own games someday?

Kasavin: We have some Oculus fans on team and are excited for how that could open up new types of gaming experiences for people, even if those experiences are quite different from the types of games we've made thus far. I don't have a good impression yet of how that tech could be used for the kinds of games we make today, as we made pure 2D games. But I am all for this kind of tech broadening the definition of what games can be and what they can do! Excited to see where it all goes.

harold.johnson asks: What's the general timeline looking like for getting Transistor onto other platforms?

Kasavin: All our focus was on our PlayStation 4 and PC launch, and beyond that we have no current plans, though nothing is ruled out either. We do intend to make native Mac and Linux versions of the game, though we have no specific timetable for that. One of the nice things about being small is we don't have to plan too far ahead!

kainen1 asks: Are there any other genres you are considering for your next game? Or will you continue with isometric adventures?

Kasavin: It's too early to say what's next for us! I'll be at least as curious as you to find out. I think we like working on stuff that puts us out of our comfort zone in some way, though how exactly that will manifest, I do not know right now. For sure we want to keep working on stuff that is creatively challenging and rewarding, and is respectful of our players' time and intelligence.

snot3353 asks: Along that same line, are you open to making your next project a sequel to Bastion or Transistor? Or do you see those as standalone and you'd rather continue making new IPs instead?

Kasavin: We haven't ruled anything out for the future, though Transistor, much like Bastion before it, was designed to be complete, so that if for some reason it were the last game we ever made, we wouldn't leave anyone hanging. At the same time, we aim to create worlds for our games that could potentially support any number of stories, though that's in the spirit of making interesting and deep-feeling worlds purely for its own sake. We hope to keep going!

Senior Editor

Ozzie has been playing video games since picking up his first NES controller at age 5. He has been into games ever since, only briefly stepping away during his college years. But he was pulled back in after spending years in QA circles for both THQ and Activision, mostly spending time helping to push forward the Guitar Hero series at its peak. Ozzie has become a big fan of platformers, puzzle games, shooters, and RPGs, just to name a few genres, but he’s also a huge sucker for anything with a good, compelling narrative behind it. Because what are video games if you can't enjoy a good story with a fresh Cherry Coke?

From The Chatty
  • reply
    May 29, 2014 10:00 AM

    Ozzie Mejia posted a new article, Chatty Q&A: Supergiant Games discusses the making of Transistor.

    After playing through Supergiant's latest, Shacknews' enthusiastic community of Chatty posters had some questions for the Transistor creators. Creative director and game writer Greg Kasavin was happy to comply and provide some valuable answers.

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 10:09 AM

      Cool, thanks for the article Ozzie.

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 10:15 AM

      I really liked the song in that early scene that was in the trailers. Its so good.

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 10:28 AM

      Great stuff Oz! Thanks for letting us get involved.

      Would love to see you do something with Transistor like you guys did with Wolfenstein. Maybe not necessarily a walk through series but something with the various Functions. IDK spitballing here but more content is great anyway it comes.

      • reply
        May 29, 2014 12:13 PM

        This is a good idea and we are looking into it.

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 10:39 AM

      Sweet I got two questions answered... thanks for letting us in on this Ozzie.

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 12:22 PM

      Excellent article. Thanks!

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 12:24 PM

      Thanks! I'm only an hour or two into the game but it has impressed me so far and I enjoyed the dev comments

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 12:25 PM

      this is the type of content i love to read

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 12:32 PM

      Good questions, the Supergiant guys are the closest I would consider an utterly complete studio and Kasavin's responses really reflect that

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 2:00 PM

      I have a strange little niche question for anybody who might know. When you play the game you sometimes see ghosts of what look like your character walking around. They just kind of fade in and out, you can easily miss it if you aren't paying attention. Are those "preprogrammed" in or are those shadows of other players actually playing the game kind of like Dark Souls?

      • reply
        May 29, 2014 4:55 PM

        I assumed they just showed you where to go if you were running around an area to long and it seemed like you were lost? Maybe it comes up later in the game?

      • reply
        May 29, 2014 5:07 PM

        I think they're supposed to be other players like Dark Souls. Not sure if they're preprogrammed or they have some basic networking built in for this but they seem pretty random. I've seen a few with notes coming off them like they were humming in place, others running around in odd places. Not exactly showing the path to take or anything.

        Would have been a good question to ask them for sure.

        • reply
          May 29, 2014 8:36 PM

          My first thought was that they were put there manually either as a guide or for atmosphere... but then a few of them seemed to be walking in very random ways which made it look like they were possibly actual people playing the game.

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 4:58 PM

      Thanks for doing this!

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 8:48 PM

      Thank you very much Ozzie. Of course I'm excited to get my question answered, but in general it's really cool to involve the community in stuff like this. Awesome.

    • reply
      May 29, 2014 9:08 PM

      I like this format...we should do more like this! bravo