Why Xbox TV originals won't be like Choose Your Own Adventure

Xbox Entertainment creative director Elan Lee explains why he doesn't see the future of interactive TV as branching paths and multiple endings.

4

Microsoft is kicking off its original TV programming on Xbox this year, and plans to take advantage of the interactivity that comes with hosting your shows on a game console. In a recent interview, Xbox Entertainment Studio creative director Elan Lee was fairly vague on just how it will be leveraging that aspect, but he was very clear on how it won't. He has no intention of making branching paths and multiple endings.

"The biggest thing that’s been tried before that I think has no future is this notion of choose-your-own-adventure," Lee told VentureBeat. "When we were kids, we all read those books. We all talked about them. But today, when you think about your favorite TV shows, your favorite characters, they go through this unbelievable conflict and at the end they come out victorious. Or, in the version you watched, I guess they didn’t come out victorious? Suddenly there’s ambiguity about how that story ended.

"For me, personally, that’s a terrible experience. I want to be in the hands of a master storyteller. I want them to tell me the saga of this character that I get to live with across three seasons, who I care about deeply. I want to know the answer to the story. I don’t want one of 10 endings. If every ending is equally valid, suddenly none of them are important. That’s a real problem."

Lee says that by comparison, a video game is uniquely your story, so having multiple endings and discussing them with friends is part of the enjoyment. A TV show with actors is more of an authored experience, and so it's more important to have a definitive plot.

As an example of what they could do, he suggests a Game of Thrones scene in which an archer shoots an arrow and you as the viewer feel it thud as it appears on your phone. That's only an example, as Microsoft doesn't produce the HBO series, but it gives an idea of the types of ideas Lee is brewing.

"That’s an ecosystem of devices, aware of its environment and aware of how to use those systems to make storytelling more immersive," he said. "That’s an arrow that was just shot into your hand. How cool is that? How can we use elements like that for deeper and more engrossing storytelling? I’m not saying we’re going to do exactly that. But being aware of what these things are capable of makes for a whole new generation of stories that the Xbox can tell."

Editor-In-Chief
From The Chatty
  • reply
    January 28, 2014 8:30 AM

    Steve Watts posted a new article, Why Xbox TV originals won't be like Choose Your Own Adventure.

    Xbox Entertainment creative director Elan Lee explains why he doesn't see the future of interactive TV as branching paths and multiple endings.

    • reply
      January 28, 2014 9:15 AM

      But how cool is that arrow the third time? This sounds like something some executive thinks is neat but has no lasting value at all. Like the Move controllers or everything being a standalone app on the One.

      • reply
        January 28, 2014 9:24 AM

        Yea, I don't know what the hell they are talking about there. Seems like a neat idea, but a rather limited idea.

        I think we SHOULD see some choose-your-own adventure type series from Xbox TV. I don't think ALL of the shows should be that way, but why not have some? Why not blur the lines between video game and television even more.

        • reply
          January 28, 2014 9:39 AM

          Choose your adventure video game/TV show hybrids would just be FMV adventure games. MS could hopefully bring the budget for production values though. That Halo live action series (from last year I think) wasn't bad for a first try, and it actually had Master Chief doing Halo stuff in it.