NVidia & ATI vs Futuremark - Shacknews - PC Games, PlayStation, Xbox 360 and Wii video game news, previews and downloads
Latest: /// NVidia 8800 = Fast

NVidia & ATI vs Futuremark

May 23, 2003 5:42pm CST tags: NVidia, Futuremark
A while back many of you may recall ATI getting caught red-handed having their drivers detect Quake3 firing up and they would drop the image quality slightly to improve benchmark scores. That was just a tiny bit of a scandal. Well now Futuremark is accusing NVidia of playing naughty when it comes to their benchmark suite:

"Recently, there have been questions and some confusion regarding 3DMark 03 results obtained with certain Nvidia" products, Futuremark said in the statement. "We have now established that Nvidia's Detonator FX drivers contain certain detection mechanisms that cause an artificially high score when using 3DMark 03."

The real question being, is NVidia dropping image quality to inflate those scores? If NVidia is simply adjusting how their driver reacts to the application to improve performance without hindering the quality, then I dont see the problem. Just about all hardware vendors do this to make sure their stuff works with the most popular game engines. Also keep in mind that NVidia (among others) has been vocal in the past about the latest 3DMark not being a very good benchmark, that could play a part in Futuremark not exactly being thrilled with NVidia and perhaps trying throw some bad mojo their way. update: It seems that ATI is also being looked at and I'm just blind (Thanks Rick):

Our investigations reveal that some drivers from ATI also produce a slightly lower total score on this new build of 3DMark03. The drop in performance on the same test system with a Radeon 9800 Pro using the Catalyst 3.4 drivers is 1.9%. This performance drop is almost entirely due to 8.2% difference in the game test 4 result, which means that the test was also detected and somehow altered by the ATI drivers. We are currently investigating this further.

update: Here is some stuff NVidia is accused of doing.
        

Related Stories

  • New Video Card Drivers

    No Comments | Jun 01, 2007 2:54pm CST

    New drivers are now available for AMD/ATI- and NVidia-powered video cards. For ForceWare 94.24 drivers for Windows XP go here. Radeon owners can find ...

  • New NVidia 7 & 8 Series Drivers

    No Comments | May 18, 2007 1:54pm CST

    NVidia has finally released new XP drivers for 7 series cards. The 94.24 drivers are available here. In addition, the 158.22 8 series drivers are ...

  • New ForceWare Drivers For XP

    13 Comments | May 03, 2007 7:40am CST

    New ForceWare drivers for GeForce 8x00 powered videocards running under Windows XP and Media Center are now available. The 158.22 release offers numer...

  • New ForceWare Drivers

    9 Comments | Apr 27, 2007 5:44am CST

    Over at the NVidia site you can find new ForceWare drivers for 32-bit and 64-bit versions of Windows Vista, adding support for newly released GeForce ...

  • NVidia ForceWare v100.65

    9 Comments | Feb 21, 2007 9:03am CST

    Forgot to mention yesterday yet another NVidia Vista driver release. These ones are somehow WHQL certified if you can believe that. They are listed a...

  • NVidia GeForce 8800 GTS 320MB Tested

    21 Comments | Feb 12, 2007 8:48am CST

    Companies are rolling out the third GeForce 8 GPU based product today, the GeForce 8800 GTS 320MB. Similar to the previous 8800 GTS, memory has been ...

  • New ForceWare Drivers

    12 Comments | Dec 08, 2006 2:50pm CST

    NVidia has released version 97.44 of the ForceWare drivers for GeForce powered videocards. This new release adds support for GeForce 8800 GTS and GTX ...

  • NVidia 8800 = Fast

    132 Comments | Nov 08, 2006 2:25pm CST

    Generally we havent been giving many big headlines to the ongoing generational improvements of videocards from NVidia and ATI but the 8800 from NVidi...

  • NVIDIA PureVideo HD Preview

    1 Comment | Nov 01, 2006 8:43am CST

    Over at FiringSquad you can find an article about the NVIDIA PureVideo HD technology, checking out the performance of its high-def video decoding....

  • New ForceWare Drivers

    35 Comments | Sep 01, 2006 2:24pm CST

    Over at the NVidia website you can now find version 91.47 of the ForceWare drivers for GeForce videocards. According to the release notes, the driver ...