• #2
    Refresh Thread
    By: Shacknews This person is cool! x Show Full Post
    Reply
    Steve Watts posted a new article, Notch refuses to help certify Minecraft for Windows 8.

    Minecraft creator Markus "Notch" Persson says he refused to help Microsoft certify Minecraft for Windows 8, saying he'd rather not have it run on the new OS at all.
    Sep 27, 2012 9:30am PDT
    toggle
    Steve Watts posted a new article, Notch refuses to help certify Minecraft for Windows 8.

    Minecraft creator Markus "Notch" Persson says he refused to help Microsoft certify Minecraft for Windows 8, saying he'd rather not have it run on the new OS at all. : ShacknewsThis person is cool!

    Thread Truncated. Click to see all 110 replies.

    • toggle
      So is the biggest complaint about Windows 8 the fact that the marketplace seems fairly integrated with th... : pigvomitThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        It seems like the biggest complaint is that it isn't optional. Some people would rather just use it they ... : BeowolfSchaefer
        • toggle
          I would bet that by the time it ships, there will be a way to enable classic mode. : UberKalden
          • It's already RTM, finished and shipping. : metalremainsThis person is cool!
          • toggle
            What does 'enable classic mode' mean? Does it mean this? http://i.imgur.com/hnV87.png Because if it does... : Memphis-Ahn
            • toggle
              The current and final version looks like this http://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/windo... : Peanut Fox
              • http://cdn.windows8update.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/Optimized-windows-8-desktop-600x337.jpg Bett... : Peanut Fox
        • Aren't they worried about the slap-down they might get from the EU and maybe US? : pigvomitThis person is cool!
        • toggle
          Of course it's optional. Not being able to uninstall it is not the same as forcing you to use it : OverloadUT
          • toggle
            As I understand it, the original Start Menu is gone. You have Metro and that's it. : Rehevkor
            • toggle
              What does that have to do with forcing people to use the app store? The Start Menu isn't "gone", it ju : OverloadUT
              • toggle
                i dont think it has anything to do with metro view, no one really cares about it, it is the fact that Mic... : CrazyRussian1989
                • toggle
                  That's not how it works with Apple and their desktop OS. You can release all the apps you want outside of... : OverloadUT
                  • right. desktop and mobile and consoles and pads have some different installation environments and require... : DownforceThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        as far as i can tell yes. While i agree there will be no compelling reason to upgrade from 7, i do not u... : UberKalden
        • toggle
          problem is they are starting to push developers to go through their so called "App store" meaning that gi... : CrazyRussian1989
          • toggle
            but don't google and apple do that for their devices? isn't MS just going with that successful framework ... : DownforceThis person is cool!
            • toggle
              Google does not and apple only does it on iOS. I assure you that should apple ever try that with desktops... : terath
              • I think he was just responding to the very first part of the aptly-named CrazyRussian's post. The "they a... : OverloadUT
      • toggle
        yes but people are retarded. Windows 8 is the EXACT same thing as windows7, as far as apps are concerned.... : mnok
        • toggle
          what developers are afraid of is Microsoft making their own App store a mandatory thing for any software/... : CrazyRussian1989
          • toggle
            That is absurd. The reason Windows is so popular is the open nature of producing desktop applications. Yo... : deject
            • toggle
              Agreed, it is absurd, but it didn't stop Microsoft from trying to close it off in some way... only time w... : CrazyRussian1989
              • But they haven't tried to do that. : deject
              • toggle
                They have not "tried to close it off in some way" at all : OverloadUT
                • toggle
                  MS is not trying to close off Windows 8 via a "certification" process for software at all and this is one... : Goto10
                  • toggle
                    They require certification if you want to be on their app store. There is no requirement to be on the app... : deject
                    • toggle
                      The only way that would be a big deal is if MS somehow someday got stupid and said only certified softwar... : Goto10
                      • There is no relation to uncertified software, at all. It will run as any desktop application does on Wind... : deject
                  • toggle
                    They are adding an app store to conveniently buy and install applications in Windows, like every other ma... : OverloadUT
                    • toggle
                      Does the certification process ensure the software plays nice with other pieces of certified software or ... : Goto10
                      • It's mostly a front end shop ease as well as to make sure your app isn't completely fucked up. It makes n... : ChodThis person is cool!
                • toggle
                  installing unsigned drivers is a pain in the ass. Makes using things like http://kxproject.lugosoft.com/... : MamiyaOtaru
                  • toggle
                    You mean how you have to click "Yes I want to install unsigned drivers"? : OverloadUT
                    • toggle
                      yes it's exactly like that http://forum.avsim.net/topic/321458-win-7-64-bit-install/ : MamiyaOtaru
                      • toggle
                        Sounds like a badly implemented driver. I've installed unsigned drivers numerous times and the only thing... : ChodThis person is cool!
                        • probably. I'm not presenting this as evidence that MS is locking everything down, just saying I can see ... : MamiyaOtaru
                      • toggle
                        same thing by someone who has heard of paragraphs http://www.flightsim.com/vbfs/showthread.php?213081-Til... : MamiyaOtaru
                        • I've installed a lot of unsigned drivers and never had to do more than click "yes" to the warning. It sou... : OverloadUT
                      • I don't think citing a post made by someone who linked an image with "file:///" really helps your case. : walker270This person is cool!
      • I don't see why, given the 'app store' approach is why I enjoy the iphone so much : avatar_58
    • I thought he wasn't even involved in any of the coding or managerial stuff for minecraft any more : bipolarThis person is cool!
    • toggle
      Notch is a prima donna news at 11 It's not different than certifying your game to be on Steam. It does... : OverloadUT
      • toggle
        Minecraft not being on Steam sort of invalidates your point. : sambront
        • toggle
          Minecraft being on XBLA and iOS validates it. WAKE UP : JohnnyRey
          • Egg-fucking-zactly. : rosewoodThis person is cool!
        • toggle
          No, you just misunderstood my point. My point is a closed marketplace merely existing doesn't make the wh... : OverloadUT
          • toggle
            It kinda does on Windows RT. : ConanThis person is cool!
            • toggle
              Well yeah but that's a unique single device; I assumed what we're talking about is personal computers. ... : OverloadUT
              • toggle
                And honestly I don't know much about Windows RT at all, and that was news to me. I'm only really speaking... : OverloadUT
                • toggle
                  It's not a "unique single device", it's a large number of the Windows 8 tablets that will be shipping - i... : ConanThis person is cool!
                  • toggle
                    Here's a video of the Asus device: http://www.theverge.com/2012/8/31/3281960/windows-rt-office-2013-rt... : ConanThis person is cool!
                    • The point is it doesn't mean that real Windows is crippled in any way. : deject
            • toggle
              As if that is any different from Android/iOS : JohnnyRey
              • It is different than Android, yes, unless you're getting a device from a carrier who is stupid and goes o... : ConanThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        i think what everyone (developers) afraid of that that 2 years down the line Microsoft won't let him sell... : CrazyRussian1989
        • toggle
          Microsoft would be hit with a shit ton of anti-trust lawsuits then. : jabuck
          • toggle
            noone is hitting tablets with these lawsuits, why would they do it to PC OS? and microsoft has all right ... : CrazyRussian1989
            • no one in the tablet market is considered a monopoly like Microsoft is with x86/x64 machines. : jabuck
        • toggle
          That won't happen for the desktop OS : OverloadUT
          • toggle
            Absolutely agreed. : deject
            • i hope you are right... i am just saying what developers are afraid of and the fact that so many of them ... : CrazyRussian1989
        • The fucking crazy crazies have been worried of that "2 years down the line" shit since Windows 95. : rosewoodThis person is cool!
    • that's too bad, i liked the xbox version : feekThis person is cool!
    • toggle
      Well apple has had much success with closing their system as much as possible. : vortex6930
      • toggle
        I'm unfamiliar with Windows 8, but using the App Store on the OSX side isn't the only way to install appl... : Ellissd
        • Same with Win 8 : OverloadUT
        • toggle
          In Win 8 their app store is not the only way to install apps either you do it normally. What MS asked is ... : valcan_sThis person is cool!
          • It's the only way to install Metro apps. : mojoald
      • LOL : valcan_sThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        Say whaat? : dumb.
        • iOS app store is extremely successful, wouldn't you agree? : lord cecilThis person is cool!
    • toggle
      As a software developer who has been through the Windows certification process with an app, I can't think... : jeffcox111
      • This ^^^ I agree, that is my experience as well with the shop I am with, its no big deal. : valcan_sThis person is cool!
    • Desktop applications can still be sold through whatever means you want, I don't know what he is complaini... : jabuck
    • lol Windows 8 is sounding like the Obama Care Debate. I might buy it, but i'll wait to see how it turns o... : saturn96This person is cool!
    • toggle
      notch is an idiot. The more I read the things he says (and I'm not just talking news blurbs, but intervie... : freakynipples69
      • toggle
        but I'll be fair and say I never had a conversation with him, so he may not be the idiot he paints himsel... : freakynipples69
        • I don't think he's an idiot, I just think he loves the attention his video game celebrity status affords ... : qwpeoriuThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        I think it's easy to confuse having a carefree attitude with being an idiot. : GoncynThis person is cool!
        • Having a strong opinion, like he has demonstrated, is not being carefree. : StealthHawkThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        JohnnyRey post wait what : deject
        • lol : JohnnyRey
      • I don't know if he's an idiot, but he did quite an idiotic thing when he funded that one tactical shooter... : The Grolar Bear
      • I am beginning to think his ego is getting to big for his hat. : deathofratsThis person is cool!
    • The Neckbeard is strong in this one. : brechtThis person is cool!
    • Like JohnnyRey said above, Minecraft being on XBLA and iOS is pretty hypocritical. : Anastomosis
    • This is like prisoners arguing over who's bitch Johnny is. : capt trippsThis person is cool!
    • So minecraft will run on W8, just not be in the app store right? If so the who the hell cares, if I were... : LiquidThis person is cool!
    • If the store offers a service like steams cross play across windows 8 devices, then i can see the benefit... : o.flaherty
    • toggle
      Notch is being a tard this time. : Memphis-Ahn
      • ptffff this time : JohnnyRey
    • toggle
      This coming from a guy whose game requires a Java VM install. lol : HalenThis person is cool!
      • you lost me on this one : MamiyaOtaru
    • I'm glad to see the intelligent people coming out. Notch here makes no sense. He's just bagging on Win8... : UCFknighthood
    • Considering Minecraft already runs perfectly fine on Windows 8 using standard install methods, this is a ... : Kojak2000
    • toggle
      So someone want to explain how the fuck this is news? : Mr Gore
      • toggle
        Shacknews is the tabloid of internet personalities. : Memphis-Ahn
        • You misspelled Kotaku : Home Nugget
      • a game developer of a fairly popular game is publicly thumbing his nose at a major platform for games. ... : harold.johnson
    • Hey the guy is standing up for something he believes in, that's commendable. : uebersoldat
    • That's pretty sad. I dislike the Windows 8. In my opinion, the Windows 7 is better than 8. : commanderxp90
    • Is there any limit to the depths of unprofessionalism this man displays? : Shadow13th
    • Is there any limit to the depths of unprofessionalism this man displays? : Shadow13th
    • toggle
      I wish people would remember. People almost always hate every new version of Windows. I remember Windows ... : shmargin
      • toggle
        Does this mean I will soon need to own 3 iphones to game in eyefinity? : dookiebot
        • It's currently up to 3 phones using Apple's new connector, though they're working on a version that suppo... : Peanut Fox
    • toggle
      Notch is entitled to his opinion, but it's fucking annoying how the gaming community puts him on a pedist... : weemanply109
      • pedestal* : weemanply109