• #217
    Refresh Thread
    By: the archvile This person is cool! x Show Full Post
    Reply
    I need to scold Jeff Cannata for jumping straight for the "Entitled" button. It seems like the word "entitled gamers" gets thrown out there as a default first defense against a bad reaction to anything, immediately placing blame on consumers wanting "too much".

    As someone who hasn't played any of the Mass Effect games, but has read about this controversy, I personally think that Mass Effect fans are "entitled" to an ending that's more substantial than a 2.5 minute Bink video with palette swaps. Is it too late to wash away the stink of that lackluster handling? Yes. Is it too late to build a new ending series that's bigger than just "press A, B, or C"? Yes. But I think that at least some text on the implications of those decisions would be better than some Bink video that was phoned into Blur studios (or whoever they had do those renders) a few months before certification.

    The multiple endings thing made me think about Catherine. Atlus had Studio 4 C make six sets of ending animations, all unique, all with dialogue. That of course requires finishing the writing ahead of time. Which makes me think: how much was BioWare making up the Mass Effect 3 story as they went along?
    Mar 24, 2012 4:18pm PDT
    toggle
    I need to scold Jeff Cannata for jumping straight for the "Entitled" button. It seems like the word "ent... : the archvileThis person is cool!

    Thread Truncated. Click to see all 27 replies.

    • as a Mass effect fan from the beginning I was perfectly satisfied with the ending. I would consider the ... : Runnermatt
    • toggle
      It's interesting. When I discuss the Mass Effect 3 ending, I always think of it from the moment Shephe... : MHSilver
      • toggle
        But at least those did wrap up something. In ME3 the "ending" would then be Shepard running downhill into... : ChaosNovaXZ
        • toggle
          That's the ending as far as Shepherd's physical impact on the battlefield, yes. It's the not ending in... : MHSilver
          • toggle
            I think ME3s ending was handled fantastically well (if we are to assume that the indoctrenation theory is... : CruelLEGACEY
            • I think it was handled fairly well, considering it's really the first time a company has tried something ... : MHSilver
            • toggle
              That's the problem though, everything can SEEM obvious when you have ALL the hints laid out for you in a ... : bebopdabebop
              • There are two major interpretations floating around, both of which involve indoctrination, and both of wh... : MHSilver
            • The flaw with the indoctrination theory is that if it's truly the case that you imagine everything that ... : kadayi
    • toggle
      Its the eternal ad hominem attack of the people with the microphones and the bylines. "Oohm a bruhuhuhuh... : DevSword
      • No, not really. It's just an accurate descriptor of attitudes and behavior. : MHSilver
      • toggle
        a few points.. -Please realize that the complainers are a vastly (although loud) small percentage of t... : Runnermatt
        • toggle
          There are plenty of internet outrages that deserve to be called out simply because they don't make sense,... : DevSword
          • Wait who the hell wanted a UMD drive on the vita??? What add a extra inch of bulk and 2 decibels of sound... : Mysssss
    • toggle
      The distinction that doesn't seem to be getting across is that "entitled gamers" isn't being used as a de... : CampKusoge
      • toggle
        Why should they express gratitude when they paid for the game? It wasn't a gift unless you ventured into... : DevSword
        • Gratitude might be a poor word choice. How about 'perspective'? Yes, they bought the game. That ent... : MHSilver
        • toggle
          I'd hate to work anywhere that has you as a customer. : CampKusoge
          • toggle
            So now the retailer deserves my gratitude when they had no part in even making the game? When you pay fo... : DevSword
            • toggle
              So giving people money earns you permission to act like a spoiled little snot? : CampKusoge
              • toggle
                Well first of all, yes, I have the right to be a "spoiled snot" if Bioware sends Cory Barlog to my house ... : DevSword
                • toggle
                  Criticize anything all you want. I'm the last person who'd deny you that. Criticism is a healthy and enti... : CampKusoge
                  • toggle
                    I don't really see the difference between voicing criticism and "throwing a tantrum." Maybe that one guy... : DevSword
                    • I can't speak for anyone but myself, but personally, I don't actually like Mass Effect to be honest. I do... : CampKusoge
    • Entitlement doesn't have a negative connotation inherently. Mass Effect 3 is a product. It was made to... : TylerAshcraft
    • I agree with almost all of what you are saying here. You are right - it's too late to wash the 'stink' a... : reego41