• #145
    Refresh Thread
    By: CruelLEGACEY x Show Full Post
    Reply
    I've gotta say, Andea's assertion that a "simple" game can't be considered a game of the year contender really got me worked up.

    Simplicity in any medium can be a sign of skill.

    As a musician, I'm never impressed by the bands that play the most notes. I'm impressed by the bands that are able to play the fewest notes, yet make a powerful piece of music.

    Yes, there is something truly impressive about a game as deep and complex as AC brotherhood or Mass Effect 2, especially when it comes all clicks.

    But that takes nothing away from a simple, elagent idea, masterfully exicuted.

    Angry Birds may or may not be a fair contender for Game of the Year. But I will say this: it captured more hours from me than Fable 3, Vanquish, Alan Wake, and a lot of other great games this year.

    Andrea's dismissal of a game, purely because it is 'simple', is a truly ignorant and closed-minded way to look at the medium.
    Feb 13, 2011 8:03pm PST
    toggle
    I've gotta say, Andea's assertion that a "simple" game can't be considered a game of the year contender r... : CruelLEGACEY

    Thread Truncated. Click to see all 8 replies.

    • Yes! I was thinking in the same music analogy. Andrea seems to think that the video game equivalent of ... : ericthecro
    • toggle
      I think that one should first consider what criteria you have to hit to be considered "Game of the Year".... : ImprobableJ
      • You make some very good points, although I personally don't feel the need to break things down quite as f... : CruelLEGACEY
      • toggle
        or we could just throw out the notion of Game of the Year altogether (a pipe dream I know) and while ... : Runnermatt
        • I agree. : Monkey0111
        • toggle
          The problem is that once you've opened that Pandora's box, you can never close it again. The moment a GOT... : ImprobableJ
          • Well you can dial back expectations. It seems to that Movies ( here I go using a comparison) once relied... : Runnermatt