Thread Truncated. Click to see all 21 replies.

• toggle

  Ep1 was good Ep2 was awesome : edge198
  • Pretty much : tcs
• ep1 is fairly good with an awesome ending. ep2 is fucking amazing with a huge difficulty spike at the ... : roushimsx
• Loved them both, played them both multiple times. Thinking about going through them again, even though I ... : Cheespuff
• a lot. : shirif
• There are a million shackers with extra copies to gift, I think, so maybe someone will be kind enough to ... : FS|Archangel
• So good : Head Rush
• They are both great, of the same caliber as the original game. Episode One is my favorite. : jeffmoeller
• Episode 1 was good. Episode 2 blew me the fuck away, got me pissed off and happy, delivered a blow to my ... : BackSinner
• Quite satisfactory : Koral06
• You could do a lot worse. : enyakk
• 1 was good, 2 was better. : lightly inclined
• I liked them individually more than HL2--which was good, just poorly paced, IMO. : David Craddock
• toggle

  My friend Tony put it best: http://www.shackpics.com/files/tony_05eg9oh0tvqqlnke79df.jpg : uglysad
  • I was expecting a different Tony. : shirif
• i thought they were both amazing : eeeealmo
• both were good, but basically more of the same. in some way they feel and play like gameplay experiments ... : Hoax
• They are both pretty good. I was just thinking about going back and playing all of them again : jeolson
• Amazing games. The end of Ep. 2 is one of my favorite endings ever. VALVE PLEASE GIVE US INFORMATION ... : freshyk
• I found them to be pretty dull : / : azuvatar