Car Dudez

I'm looking for a decent replacement for my current 2001 Celica. I really love my baby (I've had her for about 5 years now), but she's just getting old. Been through two accidents and is now sitting at around 120k miles. I got her used and her last owner really ran her through the ringer (over 100k miles). What I'd like to know is if you guys know any good models that are similar to it. I've looked at newer celicas a bit, but they're too flashy and over the top imo. The thing I liked best about my car was how it was sleek and sexy, but not in your face about it.

Do you guys have any suggestions for me for cars that follow in that line of thought? I'd like it to have at least 4 seats, but it doesn't have to be 2 door or a hatchback. Also, a newer car would be nice even though I'm planning on getting it used.