• #5986
    Refresh Thread
    By: locater16 This person is cool! x Show Full Post
    Reply
    What happened to ambitious games?

    Every Triple A game this year except Red Dead Redemption was mostly "same ol same ol, we got this, video games = teh business". As if you churned out video games like cars. Even Starcraft 2 just felt like a highly polished "New model Mercedes" that was still "give the players what they want instead of trying something new."

    There was a great, candid quote from a game developer, where I can't remember. But it was "All fans can basically think of is a mashup of what's already done." Which is what a lot of this years games felt like. Where's the Steve Jobs of the gaming industry? The guy that says "Consumers can't say what they want in a visual computing system, because they've never seen one before." I want a game I've never seen before, something crazy and ambitious and new that I can get excited about. If the second highest market cap company in the world can get to the top by taking risks then why the hell is the world's newest entertainment industry controlled by assholes who only ever approve "slightly different sequel #5,000,000,000"?

    New video game crash here we come. Assuming that this trend continues for long enough. Even Hollywood takes more risks than a lot of expensive video games did this year.
    Jan 05, 2011 4:03pm PST
    toggle
    What happened to ambitious games? Every Triple A game this year except Red Dead Redemption was mostly ... : locater16This person is cool!

    Thread Truncated. Click to see all 50 replies.

    • I don't care, I want Diablo 3 and so do you. :D : DM7
    • toggle
      I'd toss RDR in there too, it was basically GTA on a horse with a few minor innovations to make the empty... : pyideThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        Different setting than we're used to? : DM7
        • toggle
          Westerns games have been done before but yeah, that's about all there is to it to set it apart Rockstar's... : pyideThis person is cool!
          • toggle
            The "conspiracy sci-fi story thing" Assassin's Creed is doing is pretty novel by video game standards. I : ArcanumThis person is cool!
            • Bizarre indeed, and that's a good point and while I do want to see what happens next, at the same time I ... : pyideThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        Huge world (something like 32 square miles) tons of sidegames, just things like getting on and off the tr... : locater16This person is cool!
        • toggle
          So that's why the core gameplay is still a generic cover based shooter and the game and story progression... : pyideThis person is cool!
          • Agreed, it was pretty standard GTA formula : derelict515This person is cool!
          • If you don't remember what I was talking about: http://www.gta4.net/random-characters/ : pyideThis person is cool!
          • From end to end the worlds takes 20 minutes to cross on the fastest horse. But maybe I enjoyed it so much... : locater16This person is cool!
        • The amount of content isn't "staggering". There's a lot of land, but it's pretty limited in terms of thi : ArcanumThis person is cool!
        • Everything you've just described has been in previous Grand Theft games, with a different skin. Grand ... : daVinci1980
      • toggle
        Not really : justwr!ght
        • toggle
          No, he's right. It's essentially GTA in the old west. That's not a bad thing. : ArcanumThis person is cool!
          • toggle
            It's GTA with great restraint, made by people who understand how important that is to keeping the story a... : Happy Doodle Muffin
            • toggle
              Such restraint like mowing down dozens and dozens of soldiers with a gatling gun from a moving train for ... : pyideThis person is cool!
              • The very first story mission in Mexico was completely retarded. "You just killed some local peasants for : ArcanumThis person is cool!
              • Sorry, I meant to include EXCEPT EVERYTHING IN MEXICO in big bold letters. The first and last big section... : Happy Doodle Muffin
            • And as Arcanum and others have said, it's Grand Theft Horse. Well executed Grand Theft Horse. Fun game, w... : daVinci1980
    • toggle
      Ambition usually isn't profitable. Ambition involves risk; risk is bad. : the archvileThis person is cool!
      • You must be a CEO : BeowolfSchaefer
      • Sweet, I didn't know Steve Ballmer was a shacker. How's that "The iphone will never catch on" thing going... : locater16This person is cool!
      • toggle
        Risk is risk. You take risk to achieve, knowing fully you could fail. Both outcomes are possible. : silent prophet
        • toggle
          failure is generally the more likely outcome : derelict515This person is cool!
          • True. I think that's a price you have to pay to innovate. A larger probability of error and failure. In r... : silent prophet
      • No guts, no glory. : IHATEDUST
      • Yeah and it fucking blows. :( : Godhatesfatpeople
    • what happened is that budgets for AAA games ballooned to tens of millions which makes publishers incredib... : derelict515This person is cool!
    • Try http://www.mechlivinglegends.net/. Yes its mechwarrior which isn't exactly original, but I guarant... : Toth21This person is cool!
    • toggle
      You must have never played Game Dev Story. : bling1blingThis person is cool!
      • why can't we get an english localization of the PC game? :( : roushimsxThis person is cool!
    • toggle
      You're gonna wanna be checking out random european and russian stuff. : roushimsxThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        Seems like strategic games is dead in the US. meanwhile euro & russia make some great strategy games. : loke662This person is cool!
        • unfort. US loves the 3-D FPS ... i just like a little more diversity. : loke662This person is cool!
    • i know this was last year, but i really feel like demon's souls did a good job with this. in a lot of way... : mindmannThis person is cool!
    • toggle
      Because apple has something that game companies with new ideas don't have. A man that represents the com... : Lucy LabiaThis person is cool!
      • toggle
        We can't rest the future of the entire industry on Indiana Jones games, especially after that last movie. : Brian Leahy
        • I don't see why not, licensed refridgerator DLC is a completely untapped market. And for the sequel they ... : Hemtroll
      • lol no. : freakynipples69
      • toggle
        http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_leftk562o31qf8yek.gif : Godhatesfatpeople
        • Fap fap fap fap fap : freakynipples69
    • i must be a stupid idiot because i think there are ridiculous amounts of great games coming out all the t... : EvilDolemiteThis person is cool!
    • I feel late 90s early 20s were some kind of golden age were tech was advanced enough to do interesting st... : tcsThis person is cool!
    • budgets got too big. also the game industry is more mainstream, it used to be that only rich people could... : Chandler55This person is cool!
    • What happened is these games are now made by russians/ukranians/etc. I have come to the point where I wil... : Tchest
    • Making games is expensive. Making ambitious games is risky. Risky games may not make money. : freakynipples69
    • Heavy Rain was amazing : uglysad
    • There were a lot of innovative indie games though. Minecraft is one of them. : FpsnutThis person is cool!