Thread Truncated. Click to see all 147 replies.

• Probably Reach or Starcraft. : HockeyJohnston
• toggle

  Mass Effect 2! I don't see anything else coming out this year that could top it, too. : King Kavik
  • ME2 was great, but then so was Red Dead Redemption...oooh : niceguynick
  • Another vote for ME2. : chadg033
• toggle

  Enslaved : mwasher
  • A very good game -- I'm enjoying it now. : Dolemite
• I need to play through FO: NV first. : Thresher
• RDR , but I have yet to play ME2... : Metatron85
• Fallout new Vegas : Strid3rtheGreat
• toggle

  Sadly, Starcraft 2.... I havent had a lot of time to play new games though. Most of my PC time is spent w... : stygian_whisper
  • toggle

    SC2 for multi, ... ... I can't remember the best single player that I"ve played this year.. I get my year... : Demius
    • I really enjoyed the SC2 single player, and since I didnt play Mass Effect 2, or anyother crazy awesome s... : stygian_whisper
• toggle

  Minecraft Nothing else comes close : watcherxp
  • You know it! : Fenring42
  • Prosit! : uebersoldat
  • minecraft, then red dead, then me2. : slickdoody
  • Can Minecraft really count yet. It's not even really released yet since it's still alpha. : theBorgie
• toggle

  Mass Effect 2, but I've only played 3 games this year. (Splinter Cell: Conviction and BioShock 2 being th... : K1Bond007
  • The disparity in quality must be mind-blowing. I envy you : shirif
• RDR or god of war 3 : gmd
• Halo:Reach. RDR trails behind, then ME2. What an awesome year for games :D : Dave-A
• toggle

  mass effect 2. also the best video game ive ever played : mr.sleepy
  • really? i thought it was alright. not as good as the first i felt. my game of the year would have to b... : spaceless
• Reach : Evil Benius
• toggle

  Mass Effect 2 by far. BY FAR : shirif
  • This. Only game this year I've wanted to replay (and have replayed... Twice!). : Ormsbee
• Honestly, Starcraft 2. : The Grolar Bear
• Minecraft : riptyde
• Playing ME2 right now and it's completely sheleved all other games for the time being.... But I am so ... : braaains
• Mass Effect 2 with Battlefield Bad Company right behind. : kershner25
• I can't decide. So much good shit. RDR, God of War 3, Mass Effect 2, Alan Wake, Halo Reach - it's been fa... : -JLN-
• toggle

  Bayonetta. Seriously. : kallanta
  • Oh man, I forgot that was this year! Definitely a candidate, such an awesome game. : -JLN-
  • I can agree with this. : smackpiece
  • toggle

    =\ so wish i could finish this game. i suck so bad at it! WHY. : dopeman
    • just lower the difficulty if you have to - the ending and last boss fight are just TREMENDOUS : Borzoi
  • This is my pick. Though I haven't bought anything else released this year. : SigmaDraconis
• So far this year has kind of been a dud for me. My only new game purchase this year (not counting games b... : steauengeglase
• Battlefield: Bad Company 2 (I even loved the single player campaign) : mrwolf710
• Mass Effect 2!!! : Mmmmmoo
• Mass Effect 2 by far. : Sumantro
• Mass Effect 2!!! : greenbergMD
• toggle

  Minecraft if I'm being honest. FFXIII if we're only talking about commercially released games. : Vincent Grayson
  • i had to force myself to beat ffxiii, the whole game felt so closed in to me. why the hell did they get r... : spaceless
  • That game had a lot of good buried under a foot-thick layer of bullshit. I enjoyed it overall, but I wou... : kallanta
• toggle

  star trek online : CoRDS
  • @_____@ : thewindcriesmary
• Prrrrobably Mass Effect 2. Reach is a contender. If I were more into multiplayer with random Internet... : Johnny Law
• Mass Effect 2 : returnofthepanda
• Reach until new Vegas comes out : Omning
• toggle

  It's between Sam & Max: The Devil's Playhouse, ME2, and RDR for me. : pyide
  • Possibly Civilization V if they patch it up nicely. I'm still leaning towards The Devil's Playhouse t... : pyide
• toggle

  ME2, with Reach and Assassin's Creed II being close seconds. : coldfusioncs
  • toggle

    well AC2 was 2009 so that solves that problem. : waxthirteen
    • Oh shit, yes it was! Wow, I'm all kinds of confused apparently. :P : coldfusioncs
• Roy Halladay's no-hitter in the postseason, and maybe the 49ers-Saints MNF game. : Juno
• Mass Effect 2 without a shadow of doubt : CecilPhilpot
• Heavy Rain or Rock Band 3. : Deathlove
• toggle

  Mass Effect 2 or Red Dead Redemption, basically a tossup for me. : dirge23
  • Same. Both were pretty amazing. : beanman101283
• MP: Bad Company 2 SP: God of War 3 I think, but Reach's SP was pretty great too. Haven't played Mas... : Begawkiness
• Red Dead Redemption : serenj
• Super Mario Galaxy 2 : shackwack
• Starcraft 2. I haven't played too many new games this year due to unemployment though. : OmegaRed59
• I'd say Civ5 if it was more stable and bug-free at release, but I have to say Mass Effect 2. Atmosphere, ... : Nitrium
• Definitely between Bayonetta and God of War 3 for me. : choppp
• Mass Effect 2 : Thomas Hace
• Starcraft 2 even though I suck at it : .Jayson
• i have to go with Mass effect 2 for the sheer impact it had on me. even now, just recollecting on it give... : theWhite
• Minecraft, despite some recent disappointments. : Visceral Monkey
• Mount & Blade Warband : retardhumper
• Cause and Effect 2. : thecatinthehat
• toggle

  I thought ME2 was one of the more overrated games I've ever played. Can't think of anything I enjoyed abo... : DarthStank
  • toggle

    Yep you`re homo. : ToiletBomber
    • oh look guys, it's one of them! : moshman
  • You're absolutely right : Wisp!
  • Second'd. They really dumbed down ME2. For me, the best was Battlefield: Bad Company 2. A terrific mu... : progressor
• Well I'm not playing all brand new games this year, so my list would be potentially a bit weird but proba... : wytefang
• toggle

  Starcraft 2 : NexusOne
  • toggle

    Hellz no : ToiletBomber
    • "Hellz" yes noobie : moshman
• Limbo. : funnynamehere
• Sombreros - http://www.sniperdiplomat.com/?p=8 : peetabix01
• Mass Effect 2 by a mile. : adsriordan
• Mass Effect 2 : melkore
• toggle

  There's no way I can fucking decide off the top of my head. Holy shit @ the quality level of games this ... : sevogajre
  • Minecraft, Split/Second, RDR : nodebug
• toggle

  league of legends : sanewave
  • Didn't come out this year. : Wisp!
• Heavy Rain, SCII. i didnt play Red Dead RedDemption! : radula
• Starcraft 2 : Wisp!
• toggle

  SC2 - but for watching, not playing. : surround
  • toggle

    Drop7 on my iPod got the most of my time. : lpearl
    • Heroes of Newerth. I also think its interesting that noone has mentioned Civ 5. Not all that surprising ... : Nullzero
• Top 3 Contenders: RDR, Mass Effect 2, STALKER: Call of Pripyat...was that this year? It should win any... : Gojirah
• I'm kinda surprised I'm saying this, but Minecraft. Might be my goty for next year when it gets a "real"... : CaptainSurly
• Red Dead Redemption : eonix
• probably Mass Effect 2. it strangely would have been borderlands, since i had so much unexpected fun pla... : dopeman
• Starcraft 2 but only for the MP and SP - the SP alone doesn't stand up to Warcraft 3. : abrasion
• toss up between Mass Effect 2 and Red Dead Redemption. Both noticeably raised the bar in their respective... : MikkleThePickle
• Mass Effect 2, though Limbo would get a nod. : Omega Blue
• I'd say RDR. ME2 is a contender, but even though RDR is a western remake of GTA, it is still more innova... : IHATEDUST
• bad companyy 2 pc i suppose : feek
• Minecraft for its sheer potential. RDR was hell a fun too. I don't think I've been into SP things as much... : BBIJ
• toggle

  Choice paralysis. So many great games. : pigvomit
  • indeed this has been a great year for games : MikkleThePickle
• Attack of the Movies 3D : te[R]ror
• toggle

  TEAM FORTRESS 2 : mikecyb
  • HAT HATRESS HATWO : pyide
• toggle

  I'm gonna agree with Kallanta up there w/ Bayonetta, at least until Majin and Vanquish are out. : Borzoi
  • With Lost Planet 2 as my current runner up (co-op is fucking fun) until I actually buy and play Sin & Pun... : Borzoi
• StarCraft 2, with Alan Wake as a follow-up. My disappointment of the year was Mass Effect 2 :[ : razorblade79
• Tough call. Probably Red Dead Redemption with ME2 and Minecraft close behind. Alan Wake deserves an honor... : BlackCat9
• Minecraft, Civ V, Bayonetta : herradura99
• Mass Effect 2 : Maarten Goldstein
• Star2 for me : noven
• Mass Effect 2 by a long way - best game of this console generation for me. : peanut-
• GOD OF WAR 3. : kaijuseijin
• Pretty much RDR and Minecraft. : Lukiopimp
• toggle

  Mafia 2 : hanged_man
  • and BC2 : hanged_man
• Did Batman AA come out this year? If so that....at least for enjoyment. : gustjar
• Minecraft : vx2o
• Mass Effect 2 fo sho : nomaad
• Bayonetta : My Documents
• So far: Mass Effect 2 By end of the year: WoW: Cataclysm : SilverSnake
• After 70ish hours I'd go with Mass Effect 2 as far as story is concerned But I've spent more than four ti... : Cliffzorz
• ME2 // But definitely DA:O for the rpg of the year cat : Gapyro
• StarCraft 2. It's been a long time since a game hooked me in such a way and provided me with so many hun... : valael
• Amnesia, or Metro 2033 : Milleh
• toggle

  ME2, with RDR a very very close 2nd. If RDR was out on the PC I'd probably put it ahead of ME2, but the ... : dmaownsyou
  • yeah I feel the same about ME2 and RDR. : moe6
• toggle

  Bioshock 2, Minecraft, Mass Effect 2, and Alpha Protocol are the 4 I would pick from but I'm not really s... : baron calamity
  • alpha protocol would be the one. search your heart baron -- you know it to be true. : jujubeads
• vvvvvvv. It came at a time when I was getting quite tired of the big releases and wondering if I really s... : gingerninja
• Starcraft 2 by far. : razlebol
• Mass Effect 2 by a long way : Inadrys
• Mass Effect 2 : freakynipples69
• Limbo has to up there with the best, no doubt. : niceguynick
• Mass Effect 2 : armybob
• Monday Night Combat. I have by far had so much fun with this game, but New Vegas comes out in 4 DAYS! : Nerdsbeware
• Mass Effect 2. And it pleases me enough Shackers have long memories unlike most award shows. It's stil... : node
• Mass Effect 2 : theBorgie
• SC:Conviction or DR2 : thejm4n
• toggle

  Mass Effect 2 : Mmmmmoo
  • oh wait. I just replied to a near month old post. :[ : Mmmmmoo