• #17
    Refresh Thread
    By: jet-poop This person is cool! x Show Full Post
    Reply
    1. EVERY fucking wolf has a spleen. It's obvious that you're just forcing us to grind shit, don't make the grind more of a chore than it already is.

    2. There's got to be about a million more compelling quest objectives than "collect 10 gorilla nipples." If the majority of quests boil down to "[verb] [number] [noun]s" (as most of them do in MMOs, including WoW), then you have succeeded in making a boring quest that reveals to the player that they're just walking on a treadmill.

    That type of quest is ok if completing it is incidental and naturally occurs during the completion of actual interesting quests. The Witcher did a great job of this. You could pick up XP for killing x-number of something, but you would usually encounter those creatures during the completion of more interesting story quests.

    3. Make combat more interesting that [target] [press butan] [repeat]. Diablo has relatively few quests (most of them boil down to [kill boss]). Nobody minds because the combat though simple, feels good, and is fun for hours on end.

    This translates to games of any genre. A lot of modern FPS clearly spent ages on story/scripting at the expense of tuning the combat, and they get boring very quickly when you're not actually in a scripted sequence. The actual gameplay ends up feeling like filler.
    Mar 26, 2009 6:25pm PDT
    toggle
    1. EVERY fucking wolf has a spleen. It's obvious that you're just forcing us to grind shit, don't make th... : jet-poopThis person is cool!

    Thread Truncated. Click to see all 6 replies.

    • toggle
      The item-drop quests in particular have a pernicious effect of actually *discouraging* people from groupi... : SeraphielX
      • toggle
        True, but it doesn't really take any more time in this case, since you are killing those rats faster or i... : PHeeNIxxThis person is cool!
        • The problem is there are only X rats in a given area. If you were to kill them all, you'd get your items... : binaryc
    • toggle
      1. Sometimes when killing the wolf you damage the spleen, therefore a good one cannot be claimed. My tho... : GoodBoyThis person is cool!
      • I like the quests that request "pristine X" or "undamaged Y" that way I at least feel better about not ge... : binaryc