• Join Us |
  • |
  • Sign in with:

White House Against Napster

by Maarten Goldstein, Sep 09, 2000 7:04am PDT
Related Topics – RIAA

Even the White House is taking the side of the recording industry in the Napster case now, according to ZDNet. All kinds of organizations filed last-minute briefs yesterday against Napster. Besides support from the Clinton administration, the movie industry as well the NBA were offering support to the RIAA in their suit against Napster.

"Permitting Napster to shelter itself behind [the act] would defeat this basic statutory quid pro quo," the White House argued. "Napster's users would be permitted to engage in digital copying and public distribution of copyrighted works on a scale beggaring anything Congress could have imagined ... yet the music industry would receive nothing in return."




Comments

29 Threads | 74 Comments













  • The music industry deserves copyright protection when I see my slice of the $800 Million they overcharged us on CDs. The government is so beholding to the media corporation cartel that they levied NO corrective action against the industry for these actions.

    The artists have every right to be compensated for their work. Unfortunately the music industry does not compensate them in proportion to the money that is made from their work, unless they have become established. The music industry seeks to undermine the very concept of fair use.

    The US is not the only country that is under the thumb of these giant corporations. Canada was forced to tax CD-Rs to compensate the music industry for supposed losses caused by illegal copying. In Germany legislation was just passed to tax ALL computer equipment for the losses supposedly incurred by their media conglomerates. Cynics there have started calling it the "Bertleman's tax" since that company will receive a large windfall of cash ontop of already high profits.

    When my rights to fair use are again protected, when the artists receive fair compensation for their music, and when corrective action is taken against the music industry for their previous pricing policies, I will again support their right to copyright protection.