Weekend Confirmed 142 - Bioshock Infinite, Far Cry 3, Guardians of Middle-earth

By Jeff Mattas, Dec 07, 2012 11:00am PST

Today's episode of Weekend Confirmed brings together Garnett Lee, Jeff Cannata, Jeff Mattas, and special guest Nikole Zivalich, and naturally, many videogames are discussed. Cannata delivers some early (and glowing) impressions of the first couple of hours of Bioshock Infinite, Far Cry 3 gets some more time in the spotlight, and the first console MOBA, Guardians of Middle-earth, gets a bit of scrutiny. Before Finishing Moves and the post-show TailGate, the crew also chats about how best to handle Weekend Confirmed's Game of the Year awards. If you've got some feedback, a preference, or some ideas about how you think it should be handled, make yourself heard in the show comments.

Weekend Confirmed Ep. 142: 12/07/2012

Subscription Links:

Here's a handy pop-up player so you can listen from right here on the page. Let us know how it works for you.

If you're viewing this in the GameFly application, you can play Weekend Confirmed Episode 142 directly.

Weekend Confirmed comes in four segments to make it easy to listen to in segments or all at once. Here's the timing for this week's episode:

    Show Breakdown:

    Round 1 - 00:00:38 - 00:15:51

    Round 1 Part 2 – 00:16:49 – 00:29:33

    Whatcha' Been Playin Part 1 - 00:30:15 - 00:58:51

    Whatcha Been Playin Part 2 00:59:24 - 01:28:33

    Listener Feedback/Front Page News - 01:29:08 - 02:05:07

    Tailgate - 02:05:53 - 02:12:18

Follow the Weekend Confirmed crew on Twitter, too!

Weekend Confirmed @WeekendConfirmd

Garnett Lee @GarnettLee

Jeff Cannata @jeffcannata

Jeff Mattas @JeffMattas

Nikole Zivalich @NikoleZ

Remember to join the Official Facebook Weekend Confirmed Page and add us to your Facebook routine. We'll be keeping you up with the latest on the show there as well.

Original music in the show by Del Rio. Get his latest Album, Club Tipsy on iTunes. Check out more, including the Super Mega Worm mix and other mash-ups on his ReverbNation page or Facebook page, and follow him on twitter @delriomusic.

Click here to comment...

Comments

  • Garnet I really did not think you explained your opposition to doing GOTY awards by genre. Genre is the only way that makes the results useful to gamers. I use GOTY results to decide what I need to go back and play, or what to recommend to friends. For example, I picked up Red Dead and Saint's Row III ONLY because of Giant Bomb's GOTY discussion around those games. Hearing someone passionately defend their choice really motivates you to go check a game out.

    Why by genre? Because frankly, most gamers do not enjoy all types of games. I think you game journalists are unique/rare in your love of everything from platformers to shooters to text adventures to MMOs. Most gamers I know stick to one or two types of games. Sports games? Don't care. Racing games? Don't care. IOS games? Don't care. Etc.

    The fact that it can be difficult to decide whether a game is action, adventure, or RPG is no problem at all. First, a game DOES NOT have to fall in one category! There's nothing wrong with saying Red Dead competes in the action/adventure, RPG, open world, and multiplayer categories, or whatever. Second, the discussions around what genres are game falls into are themselves important! If I like RPGs, but not so much action, then when you tell me about all the great RPG elements in Red Dead, my ears perk up. Its useful information!

    I get that certain games like Journey are hard to place in a genre because they are almost in their own genre or something. Well, if you feel it deserves it, just create a new genre to describe the type of experience the game gives you, and have it win that genre! Journey does seem like a new type of game and there's nothing wrong with recognizing that, just like "MOBA"s are their own genre. There are lots of mini-genres that should get more recognition, like my current favorite type of game is "multiplayer simulation" (World of tanks and Mechwarrior Online). I have had more fun playing these games than just about anything else this year, and its mostly because I just like this TYPE of game. They feel way more complex and tactical than the typical multiplayer shooter.

    The other ways of doing it are strange. Basically any categorization where you add caveats doesn't make sense to me:

    "Its really good...for a $25 game."
    "Its really good...for an Xbox game."
    "Its really good...for a downloadable game."

    Price point? GOTY isn't about value for dollar, its about the BEST. Platform? Many hardcore gamers own more than one platform. I bought a PS3 specifically to play Uncharted, again based on GOTY discussions.

    Genre isn't a caveat. You wouldn't say "Skyrim is really good...for an RPG". Gamers prefer certain genres, gamers get in the mood for a certain genre. I don't think gamers get in the mood for a game of a certain price point "I feel like playing a $10 game today!" or certain platform, except to the degree that those things actually refer to genres/styles of games like "I'd like to play a Kinect game" or "I'd like to play an artistic platformer (i.e. downloadable game)."