Morning Discussion

Thread Truncated. Click to see all 370 replies.

• In mp it appears to be a donkey with a golden mane. : uncle slappy
• toggle

  take out your cattlemans revolver or your carbine repeater, notice all the gold bits? GOLDEN GUNS BABY. : massdev
  • toggle

    So it's just for those 2? I bought a shotgun because I loooove shotguns in video games, and it wasn't gol... : hoov1185
    • toggle

      The effect +fame to all your deeds is still present regardless of the golden bits. Based on all the weapo... : massdev
      • Good to know, thanks. : hoov1185
• toggle

  the honor system in this game is so stupid some times. i see this hooker getting beat up by some dude out... : maulla
  • No I think it considers the event over once you hogtie the person, so shooting him after is like shooting... : clain
  • Nope; you can kill as long as he is trying to harm someone. Once you take him away from the act you a bad... : massdev
  • I don't know how shooting would have turned out, but: -Gain honor for saving lady -Lose honor for sli... : ramshot
  • toggle

    I had the same incident, and blew the guy away with no penalty. Here's the deal: When an NPC is committin... : silent prophet
    • toggle

      Not quite true. I've shot him while he's threatening the whore, and I lost honor (but didn't get a bount... : Arcanum
      • Actually, a number of the random events are semi-broken. : Arcanum
  • toggle

    hahaha, slitting some dudes throat after you hogtie him is fucked up dude. : MagicWishMonkey
    • toggle

      yeah it's hilarious that he's confused at the moral implications of doing that. :) : kek
      • toggle

        warcow = D-FENS : silent prophet
        • toggle

          warcrow : warcrow
          • moo : silent prophet
          • toggle

            u r not r : ChibiJosh
            • toggle

              You mean E? : warcrow
              • Your shackname is like an optical illusion. Swear to god. : KxRook
    • bro this isn't berkeley! we're in the wild west! feed 'em to the pigs! : xxiv
  • toggle

    no i shot some dude that was about to stab a bitch and i got thanked and +honor. : xxiv
    • toggle

      You should have tied him up and shot him in the back of the head gangsta style for maximum honor points : MagicWishMonkey
      • can you do that?? i want to brand THUG LIFE on my horses ass. : xxiv
  • toggle

    Yeah at one point I hogtied a bad guy and when I brought him to the Armadillo sheriff's office nobody wou... : boring gegtik
    • toggle

      Like others said, it seems that the "evil act" is over once you interrupt it. so wtf am i supposed to do ... : maulla
      • toggle

        Ride him out into the desert and leave him there. : silent prophet
        • the real answer is to just let the hooker die next time : maulla
      • toggle

        I believe the most points you could possible get would be to enter dead eye, disarm, and hat shot. : massdev
        • toggle

          how do you enter dead eye? (I guess I should read the manual sometime, lol) : MagicWishMonkey
          • toggle

            RB3 or whatever it's called. press the right stick down. : xxiv
            • toggle

              Cool, does it slow shit down or something? I wonder why the tutorial didn't mention it. Reminds me of ... : MagicWishMonkey
              • toggle

                yeah it goes all max payne / matrix style. the red gauge on the other side of your horses stamina is your... : xxiv
                • toggle

                  Sweet, I'll have to check it out. Yea my 360 RROD'd the other day, but I slammed it down on my bed a f... : MagicWishMonkey
                  • LOL. : xxiv
              • toggle

                I think it's mentioned in one of those black boxes that pop up, but right in the middle of a fucking gun ... : Clasifyd
                • toggle

                  I HATE THAT. i had a random encounter where some guy rides up, asks me to save his buddy. so i ride wi : xxiv
                  • toggle

                    that one came up for me a total of 4 times so far and I failed every one.. if it comes up for you again s... : sludge vohaul
                    • I am so tired of that mission. "Sir sir, my wife is in trouble can you help us..." <rides away at : trove
                • The tutorials in this game are so mixed in implementation. I was 2-3 hours in and haven't used the dead e... : Sailor of Fortune
                • toggle

                  It's explained in a tutorial during a mission for that elixer salesman. : riptyde
                  • Level 2 was. Level 1 was explained way way before. : sigpro
              • toggle

                it was mentioned in the very first mission when you are killing the animals on the ranch patrol the pl... : maulla
                • toggle

                  I can't even read the shit most of the time, the text is too small and it always pops up while I'm in the... : MagicWishMonkey
                  • They put all your messages in your Journal. I sometimes have to pause and read the Journal to see the dam... : Eric2025
          • toggle

            you have to fill your dead eye guage with head shots, disarms and kills. Then on the PS3 hold L2 to AIM t... : massdev
            • toggle

              That sounds awesome, I could have used that during the bandit camp mission with the sheriff : MagicWishMonkey
              • toggle

                that's about as far as i am. i keep trying to loot the dead guys instead of staying up with the npc's : xxiv
                • haha, me too. I swear one time I looted someone and it gave me -100 honor or something, I don't know ... : MagicWishMonkey
            • toggle

              Even at lvl 3 I still just hit R2 to fire off a shot without painting the target. : darcspeed
              • You can do that but you will get situations where you need to hit many targets at once without letting an... : massdev
            • toggle

              how do you know what level its at? in SP all Ive ever been able to do is slow down time and take individu... : maulla
              • toggle

                It will unlock and give you a flash title on screen and these are scripted events so you can't really mis... : massdev
                • toggle

                  ah ok, I thought I should be looking at something on the meter itself : maulla
                  • toggle

                    Prepare to be disappointed when you get level 2. It's actually less useful than level 1. : Arcanum
                    • toggle

                      it sounds exactly like how dead eye is implemented in multiplayer. you can choose how many targets it pai... : maulla
                      • toggle

                        The issue with level 2 is that is automatically paints markers on any valid target your crosshairs touch.... : Arcanum
                        • toggle

                          I haven't run into that problem. Also you can cancel the dead eye by pressing the stick again so if you p... : sigpro
                          • toggle

                            or letting go of the left trigger : maulla
                            • toggle

                              doing that at level 2 will fire shots I think if you have anything marked. : sigpro
                              • It seems to like sometimes it does, and sometimes it doesn't. : Arcanum
      • toggle

        Set up a tent and get a fire going, sit there for a few days and watch him die of dehydration all while b... : _jon
        • ermm.... "butt chugging"? : ezkilla2
    • I carried one of my victims like that to the approaching train. The resulting collision was a blast. : Sailor of Fortune
  • Think of it this way, if a cop shot a guy assaulting a woman, it would be ok. If a cop cuffed the guy and... : uncle slappy
  • i shot the guy didnt get any penality : Frush81
  • #215

    Refresh Thread

    By: boarder2 x Show Full Post

    Reply

    I will see people running along being shot after while I'm riding down the trail and I always seem to end up shooting the wrong person. It's hard to tell who's shooting who.
    
    Or maybe I'm just supposed to leave those guys to their own problems.

    May 21, 2010 6:06am PDT
    toggle

    I will see people running along being shot after while I'm riding down the trail and I always seem to end... : boarder2
    • I'm too righteous to simply let that sort of shit fly I figure half the time I'm doing good and the ot... : boring gegtik
    • this happened to me last night. I was riding along and heard gunfire, then a message popped up saying "sa... : zerog83
    • toggle

      Haha yeah I think I ended up shooting a Sheriff who was chasing 2 bad guys. I shot all 3 because I couldn... : hoov1185
      • toggle

        In those events the guy running away from the other two is always the bad guy. As far as I can tell, any... : Arcanum
        • yeah i learned to stay out of other people business unless i'm sure. : xxiv
    • I always just look to see who is wearing a badge. : unjustend
    • The lawmen have shiny badges that glimmer on their chests. I noticed in one encounter where they weren't ... : Sailor of Fortune
  • Pretty sure you're supposed to knock the guy out, hogtie the girl and take her upstairs for maximum honor : twifosp
  • toggle

    Haha, and what everyone said above is the case, once you save her the deed is done. Also, it reminds m... : Sailor of Fortune
    • Western Justice! : sogelegos
• toggle

  I just started yesterday, where the hell are the rabbits!! : Frush81
  • toggle

    They are small and black. They tend to run out from brush when you are riding through it. : silent prophet
    • toggle

      im colorblind.. cant see the little bastards : Frush81
      • Aww, that sucks. They are really hard to see under normal conditions too. You basically have to go lookin... : silent prophet
      • uhh they're black lmao : boring gegtik
  • just ride along the trails for a bit and they'll pop up. : Sailor of Fortune
  • They tend to hang out in the outskirts of towns. : chrisschutz
• toggle

  Does anyone really understand how dueling works? : Arcanum
  • toggle

    Pull LT, dead aim should automatically start, use the right stick to dot your opponant and click the RT S... : warcrow
    • toggle

      I could've sworn I tried that and it didn't work. : Arcanum
      • toggle

        Wait till it says "Draw" then hold l2 which will charge your guage, move the right stick to aim the targe... : massdev
        • toggle

          What does the gauge actually freaking mean? : Arcanum
          • toggle

            Basically the gauge is a measure of who is winning. By assigning multiple targets you fill the gauge but ... : massdev
            • Huh, ok, thanks. : Arcanum
• toggle

  I haven't been able to play much but I did for a little bit yesterday. I got into the poker game and I lo... : NukemFornever
  • ...he shot himself? awesome. : dedgecko
• toggle

  btw am I suppose to do something if I see a bunch of guy running in town with a guy (bare with me im fre... : Frush81
  • toggle

    who knows. I got shot at by some outlaws storming through armadillo, and when i shot one of them back I g... : maulla
    • toggle

      It's depressingly easy to get the law after you accidentally. If you so much as point your weapon (even ... : Arcanum
      • If you are running to fast in town and bump into someone you get someone shooting at you, you shoot back ... : trove
  • I wouldn't. You got your own problems without worrying about others. :) : silent prophet
  • toggle

    kill them all (dead eye helps immensely) : darcspeed
    • toggle

      how do you use dead eye? it's the red bar on the left of the map I assume? : NukemFornever
      • yep : xxiv
      • oh ps3 you press R3 (the right analog button) : Frush81
      • toggle

        too bad we cant use it when ridding horses : Frush81
        • You can...? : Arcanum
        • toggle

          ? you can use dead eye while on a horse : maulla
          • toggle

            ya? when I press R3 while ridding it looks behind me : Frush81
            • nm i have to press r1 + r3 : Frush81
            • you have to be aiming your weapon to be able to use the ability : maulla
        • One of my patent pending ultra cowboy moves is from horseback with hostage situations is ride hard at the... : massdev
    • Yea I killed all 4 of the bandits with dead aim. : warcrow
    • toggle

      Ah, so the riders are BAD guys and not a sherrif's posse lynching a bad guy. I'll keep this in mind. ... : Lucien Irenicus
      • toggle

        Yea it can be tough to determine sometimes. What I find myself doing in these kinds of situations (like ... : warcrow
        • excellent idea, thanks! : Lucien Irenicus
        • very nice... : at0micgarden
        • toggle

          I just wish your little white dot when targetting changed color based on who you're aiming at. Blue would... : Entity
          • toggle

            It does for me. I've noticed when on a mission and you accidentally target one of the NPC's it will turn... : atom519
            • Yea it's only on missions and it will block you from firing at friendlies. I'm glad it doesn't block you ... : chowderman2000
      • toggle

        I fired 4 shots into the air wildly and then shot a horse for this event. :/ : quartic0
        • toggle

          Jumpy aint'cha. *tap tap* OSHI *BLAM BLAM BLAM BLAM!* : Lucien Irenicus
          • Haha, yeah. I'm even worse in games with 'scary' moments. : quartic0
• toggle

  What the hell is up with Marston in the intro sequence? Oh hey, there are three guys with rifles trained : silent prophet
  • I'm pretty sure this was intentional on his part. : deadhorse
• toggle

  You can go to Mexico? I shouldn't have read that spoiler.. : Flinz
  • yes : smax
  • toggle

    It's essentially in the trailers and it's on both maps. :) I tagged it just to be safe. BTW did you also : warcrow
    • toggle

      Yeah, that is only slightly more of a spoiler than "Tony Stark is Iron Man". : Arcanum
      • WHOA WHOA WHOA : Ebu
    • toggle

      so does that mean that the actual map expands and the game world gets much larger? or is it just a small : maulla
      • I'm pretty sure the in-game map shows the tex-mex border that you cross into Mexico and the territory sou... : at0micgarden
  • toggle

    It's not a spoiler if you have watched any media for this game at all. I don't know why everyone is treat... : gooblerampling
    • toggle

      Maybe people were expecting Canada : Sailor of Fortune
      • I wanted RDR in Antarctica. : Scotty22
• toggle

  Great games last night fellas. OMGPOSTALCOW and I kill 2 other dudes off a 2-man wagon then went riding a... : zuff
  • toggle

    zuff, I'm sorry I didn't accept your invite last night, I was just about to head to bed =( : Clasifyd
    • I'll never forgive you! >:( : zuff
• toggle

  Is there any way to see what breed of horse you're currently riding? When you break a new horse, do you k... : rudds
  • This I would like to know as well! : zuff
  • toggle

    Where do you get saddle for a new horse that you break? : Skoal^Fyfan
    • Hitch it outside one of your home locations, then sleep/save. : Arcanum
    • toggle

      Just hich it up, go play some poker & come back in a few and she'll be ready to roll. :) : warcrow
      • toggle

        do saddles matter? : at0micgarden
        • Ever riden a horse bareback? :O : warcrow
  • toggle

    Good question. I'm currently trying to figure this out too. I purchased a new horse & I have no idea wher... : warcrow
    • toggle

      press select or start, scroll to consumables, highlight the dead and use it, then up on the d pad to whis... : massdev
      • Ooooooh! : warcrow
      • FYI this ALSO works if some lying, thieving cunt of a whore bitch steals your horse and rides over a hill... : Lucien Irenicus
  • toggle

    Here's some horse info. You should learn the descriptions of the various horses from the general store. T... : massdev
    • toggle

      If you see a random horse out grazing how can you tell if it's good or not? : MagicWishMonkey
      • toggle

        There is 3 ratings; 1 star slow low stamina fugly looking (skinny, bony, diseased), 2 star normal speed a : massdev
        • toggle

          I did the herd the horses to the canyon, then chase down the gold looking horse and break it... is that t : MagicWishMonkey
          • toggle

            The stars are visible on the horse deeds in the general stores. : ZTac
            • toggle

              How can I look at a physical horse and tell what it is? : MagicWishMonkey
              • toggle

                There is currently no visual reference of what the horse is other than the general store deed description... : massdev
                • All the horses look the same to me :( Shit. : MagicWishMonkey
                • toggle

                  Some of the horses look skinny. You can see their ribs. Especially when you get to MEXICO you see a lot... : twifosp
                  • toggle

                    Well, I would like to be able to see if a horse is worthwhile or not before going through the effort of b... : MagicWishMonkey
                    • toggle

                      Aside from the ones where you can see their ribs, and the Kentucky Saddler, I'm pretty sure they're all i... : Arcanum
                      • toggle

                        So, assuming I already have the Kentucky Saddler, it wouldn't be worth my time to check out a different h... : MagicWishMonkey
                        • That is my understanding. I think 3 star is the max and there are no attributes outside of stanima, spee... : twifosp
                        • That's my thought, unless there are other 3-star horses out there that I'm unaware of. Even then, they... : Arcanum
                    • As far as I know, the 3 star horses all have the same color shade and features. So you kind of have to m... : twifosp
                    • toggle

                      Basically the three 3 star horses are gold and pearl, Kentucky Saddler. Hungarian which is white with a b... : massdev
                      • Are all the 3 star horses pretty much the same? : MagicWishMonkey
                      • toggle

                        ^^^^^ read this people. : ArtilleryMarker
                        • But sadly, having glanced at the game guide, I know those three are the best (aside from the warhorse). : ArtilleryMarker
                    • toggle

                      There are only three fast horses, the golden horse from bonnie, the white one found in mexico and the bla... : klearlyunseen
                      • Also, the war horse is equal to those three : chrisschutz
                  • toggle

                    Here comes the ban hammer! : massdev
                    • toggle

                      I don't understand why that is considered a spoiler... has there ever been a western that *didn't* involv : MagicWishMonkey
                      • toggle

                        It is pretty much the dumbest spoiler ever. It's like telling someone that the core blows up in Half-lif... : twifosp
                        • no its like saying how you go to Xen and fight other worldly beings in HL : dantastic
                      • I am not a mod, my insight ends here. : massdev
                    • toggle

                      Not a spoiler at all, it's in every trailer and it shows it on the map that comes with the game and the i... : at0micgarden
                      • not everyone watches trailers!! omg my game is ruined :( : unjustend
        • I rode that fucker off a cliff, I was so bummed :( : timaste
        • Is it the horse you get from her dad? (Mine is blonde). : eonix
    • toggle

      Do they gather in the corral over at MacFarlanes when you get the deed? I mean that's the only thing that... : warcrow
      • Not that I know of. Most of the time the horse when not in use will be hitched in the nearest location. I... : massdev
    • toggle

      Knowing that the horse deed has unlimited uses is nice to know! I haven't had occasion to use one yet (I... : ZTac
      • toggle

        I didn't know until I killed my horse jumping off rio bravo by mistake. it was a 1500 dollar fuck up whic... : massdev
        • toggle

          So you can own more than one horse and spawn them at will from your inventory? : Sailor of Fortune
          • Yep. : chrisschutz
        • Not true. If you click the deed an whistle the new one comes right away : chrisschutz
  • toggle

    I'd love to know this, I'd invest some time in wrangling horses if it meant I could rope and tame my own ... : Lucien Irenicus
    • toggle

      I really need to get this lasso. : unjustend
      • Bonny missions, do them. : ArtilleryMarker
• toggle

  Stayed up way too late playing this last night. Really, really enjoying it still. So glad Rockstar ... : atom519
  • The snipers rifle has unsurpassed range, but everything is manual, and down the scope it has very limited... : massdev
  • toggle

    Great for bounty hunting! Sit up on a ridge, take out posse, shoot bounty in the leg and work your way up... : zuff
    • toggle

      Cool! I won some good money playing blackjack, and was thinking about spending it on a new rifle with sc... : atom519
      • I have 'headshot syndrome' also. I played fallout 3 for 3-4 months before I realized there were death ani... : quartic0
  • toggle

    Here's an example of what the sniper rifle can accomplish in capable hands. http://i85.photobucket.com... : sogelegos
    • Ah-hahaha. That's awesome. : ZTac
• I can't get the hang of dueling to save my life :( also why does everyone hate the jews in this game? You... : Silent Wolf
• toggle

  There are Mexicans in this game? Fuck that. Back to Forza. : Lunatic Angelic
  • ^^ this : Ulfie
  • toggle

    Yes, but no JEWS. : Lucien Irenicus
    • toggle

      I've heard a few jew jokes playing hold em : sludge vohaul
      • toggle

        One of the shopkeeps will assure you that he carries no Jewish goods in his store. : sogelegos
        • cock suckers : dedgecko
• toggle

  In your face dedgecko: http://www.shacknews.com/onearticle.x/63918 : zuff
  • It's all in good fun :P : zuff
  • toggle

    glad to see that they are addressing this stuff quickly : maulla
    • Last night everything seemed to be getting better server-side. I hope it's flawless now with no more drop... : zuff
  • toggle

    DIAF fanboi : dedgecko
    • toggle

      :( : zuff
      • toggle

        In a much more constructive tone. I find it interesting that an update was pushed through the consoles... : dedgecko
        • That's a good point. : Nitrium
• mother fu puma!! : Frush81
• toggle

  Last night during a thunderstorm I lost big at Poker in Armadillo in the dim, dusty old room in the back ... : at0micgarden
  • toggle

    Haha nice. I did something pretty similar involving hogtieing a lawman and throwing him on the tracks. ... : atom519
    • toggle

      I wish you could drive the trains! : at0micgarden
      • that's a goddamn tragedy. : dedgecko
      • toggle

        Yeah, I was surprised that I wasn't able to drive the train or get any money out of it. Although, I gues... : atom519
        • It's pretty surprising that they wouldn't have made it a bigger focal to the game. It would be nice if y... : dedgecko
  • EXCELLENT story! One of the best I've read so far. :) : zuff
  • great story sir hope ill meet you in a camp somewhere : Frush81
  • I wish there was more than one train! It takes forever to get to it! : hussdelrio
• The ultimate irony is I still haven't had a chance to really play at home by myself yet. So fucking busy ... : bozer
• toggle

  warcrow its not a spoiler : oHnOES
  • i assume its the spoiler you laid out yesterday... tsk tsk : dantastic
  • I'm being safe. ;( : warcrow
• toggle

  Do the poker players cheat? I know you can cheat if you unlock a certain outfit or whatever, but does an... : twifosp
  • toggle

    I don't think so. You can beat up the AI pretty bad if you just bet aggressive. Keep quadrupling the bet ... : silent prophet
    • toggle

      Yea I would regularly clean out the table in like 5 minutes in Armadillo. Then you get to mexico and all... : twifosp
      • hahaha thanks for the heads up. I will keep my gun ready for any miraculous winning streaks. :) : silent prophet
      • toggle

        I got pwned in Liars Dice last night when it was just me and one other NPC. He had all five dice left an... : riptyde
        • toggle

          I really don't get that game. : trove
          • It took me a while to figure it out. Same with horseshoes, although I feel like I pwn at them now. What... : atom519
          • It took me a couple games to get the hand of it but it works like this: - Everyone gets 5 dice to star... : snot3353
          • toggle

            It's pretty simple. You are basically calling how many of a certain die are on the table (including your... : riptyde
            • I didn't realize that about the AI. Maybe I'll try it some more. : trove
        • toggle

          I've noticed the AI will call some BS out their ass on their first bet in liars dice even without looking... : sigpro
          • toggle

            If you go with simple probability you'll generally win most of the time. For example if I have two 6s an... : riptyde
            • yeah it wasn't too hard to win the one game of it I've played since I have played in before at a friend's... : sigpro
      • toggle

        Well the question is, did he have all the money he won on his body after you shot him dead? : snot3353
        • toggle

          You just loot it right? I don't remember if I got it all back or not. Why would that matter though? : twifosp
          • Because why bother shooting a guy for cheating if you can't loot all the money he won off his corpse? Tha... : snot3353
  • toggle

    In Armadillo, I found a room next door that allowed me to cheat at poker? How the fuck is that possible?... : jingletard
    • toggle

      i just wear the outfit that lets me cheat at poker. Cheating is quite handy :) : -=kodiak=-
      • toggle

        Yeah, but why did a room trigger the cheating thing? Is there some way to cheat by peeking through a hol... : jingletard
        • i dont know anything about that room :| : -=kodiak=-
  • toggle

    I had like $800 from bankrupting two players, but when I stood up, I only had like $150. Not sure what wa... : zohar79
    • Keep in mind that the pot size is not how much profit you made. Example: If the NPC bets $7 and you rai... : riptyde
    • Perhaps you confused cash with chips? That mechanic confuses me. : at0micgarden
    • toggle

      The amount of chips is not the same as the amount of money you're playing for. At Armadillo poker it a... : silent prophet
      • Ahh, okay that's it. : zohar79
• note to selft: dont go afk when your horse is standing on the railroad,.. might have a surprise when you ... : Frush81
• Last night my posse and I were have a shootout with the law in the Armadilo saloon. I escaped by jumping ... : saunders45
• toggle

  which player model are you in multiplayer? I'm the fat mexican with a sombrero riding a donkey : wtf242
  • the second or third lawman, not sure. He's got a blue coat and blonde hair. : zuff
  • toggle

    same, that donkey fucking sucks : vov1n
    • toggle

      yeah really.. he can't even jump over fences : wtf242
      • toggle

        you know you can steal real horses... : at0micgarden
        • i played for 5 minutes and got killed about 100 times by a bunch of dudes who sounded like they were 8 ye... : wtf242
  • I'm the fat mexican too. Except i'm riding what looks like a Zombie Horse. : DrZettl
  • I use the last mexican dude. The fat guy doesnt hide very well, and I like the last guys black sombrero. : Tommy Toolbag
  • The second cattle wrangler. He's got chaps!!! : saunders45
• toggle

  Still regretting having purchased it, though I have played it now. : Ebu
  • toggle

    did you get GTA IV? Why did you purchase RDR? : dedgecko
    • toggle

      Hype machine :( : Ebu
      • toggle

        Well sell it ASAP to recover your losses. I'll take it from you for $7.50 : dedgecko
        • toggle

          Yeah, I'd buy it off you if the price is right. My brother needs a copy. : atom519
          • toggle

            the question is though... 360 / PS3? And did he use his codes yet? --because you're sitting on a gold : dedgecko
            • toggle

              PS3, only code I got was the golden guns thing from Amazon; they finally decided to email it to me yester... : Ebu
              • toggle

                ah, shucks - nevermind then. : atom519
                • that's what I thought... no PS3, yet. : dedgecko
      • i felt the same way and i've never had any interest in GTA games outside of getting in a car and causing ... : valael
  • Sucks to be you. : twifosp
  • toggle

    why did you open it if it already regretted buying it : oHnOES
    • toggle

      Because I figured there was a chance I'd be wrong. I don't dislike the game, but it's just flawed eno... : Ebu
      • toggle

        How many hours have you put into it? It starts slow, and doesn't start distancing itself from GTAIV unti... : atom519
        • I've got close to 10 hours in? Something like that. It's not the story that I have an issue with, the sto... : Ebu
  • toggle

    woe is me. at least explain why. : atom519
    • Why? I'll get the same exact "You are wrong" response either way. Once the hype train gets momentum, you ... : Ebu
  • toggle

    update: first lick of ice cream - it was too cold, regretting purchase. : azenmaster
    • I consider two evenings worth of playtime sufficient to develop an opinion, thank you very much Asian Mas... : Ebu
  • toggle

    what dont you like about (still sitting on fence) : cptstern
    • toggle

      Other people like it. : twifosp
      • toggle

        Shut up : Ebu
        • toggle

          What games do you like, out of curiosity? : twifosp
          • Ghostbusters on the NES Superman on the NES Superman 64 Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing : guido anchovy
          • toggle

            You got me. I don't like any games at all. I'm a character account for Lieberman trying to destroy the ga... : Ebu
            • I knew it! Bringing it down from the inside. : guido anchovy
    • toggle

      Firstly, I'm not a fan of the western setting; I don't dislike them, but I don't watch westerns or really... : Ebu
      • toggle

        You're not a fan of the western setting? You don't enjoy the setting and don't watch much westerns? You... : tarsius
        • toggle

          http://www.shacknews.com/laryn.x?id=23006304 : Ebu
          • That didn't answer my question. The western setting did not appeal to you at all.. yet you bought the gam... : tarsius
      • You can change the way the horse controls in settings. I changes it to camera oriented and the horse hand... : Sailor of Fortune
      • I bought Need for Speed once but returned it because it was a racing game. : eonix
  • You continue to be the anti-me in videogames. :( I could almost go by whatever game you hate I would love... : kelerian
  • toggle

    Why did you regret it prior to playing it? : riptyde
    • Western GTA. The setting doesn't appeal to me at all. I didn't even know it was a Rockstar game when I or... : Ebu
  • toggle

    I'm not regretting the purchase, but I dont think it deserves a lot of the praise its received. its a rel... : maulla
    • toggle

      This is what I'm saying. I mainly regret it because I paid $60 for it, and it's not a setting that I ... : Ebu
      • toggle

        You are one of the most illogical consumers I have ever seen. If the $60 is such a sticking point, I wou... : MaxPete82
        • Who was that shacker who bought a 360, sold it and bought a PS3, then sold that and bought another 360? : riptyde
      • toggle

        well, if that is your reasoning then its your own fault and not the games. why would you even consider bu... : maulla
        • toggle

          No kidding, the flaws of GTA IV (console) are the reasons why I didn't get RDR (console), and also why I' : dedgecko
          • He's gonna have to start stealing baby food from the supermarket or have his mom die because he has no mo... : Sailor of Fortune
        • I didn't say it was the games fault... : Ebu
      • toggle

        You should have watched the video review of it on Gametrailers. It would have showed you what to expect s... : Sailor of Fortune
        • toggle

          Yea, I avoided it because I'm used to game reviews being HUGE spoilers, much like movie trailers. Oh well... : Ebu
          • GT does a great job of never spoiling anything in their reviews. You might see some stuff showing off gam... : Sailor of Fortune
• toggle

  Has anyone tried to lasso a mountain lion and bring it into town? : twifosp
  • I've tried with bucks. Once I get off the horse, the buck yanks and pulls me to the ground and breaks fre... : Tommy Toolbag
  • I lasso'd a deer and it put me on my face. : kelerian
  • yeah that's what I want to do, tether the extremely deadly fanged killing machine to the back of my horse... : darcspeed
  • lol that can't possibly end well : riptyde
  • it would be badass if you could tame it : feek
• toggle

  Has anyone found a way to sell the horses you tame in the wild? : at0micgarden
  • toggle

    I haven't, and I'm starting to wonder if you can at all. Given that the fine for horse thievery is only ... : riptyde
    • toggle

      It's one thing I do wish the game had: The ability to purchase a stable so you can collect and buy/sell h... : riptyde
      • I wanted to have the ability it buy up towns ad become the industrialist or something. Put the law in my ... : Sailor of Fortune
• FREE ROAM UNLOCK LIST: http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Multiplayer : saunders45
• Hey someone add xbox live: Tomb of Soldier for when Amazon finally fucking gets it to me next week! : locater16
• toggle

  i get distracted so easily in this game. i'll set a waypoint, head out, and on the way to my mission i'll... : [fry]
  • toggle

    Yeah I try to avoid fast-travel entirely because there are just so many things to see and shoot at. I'm ... : riptyde
    • Same. Except I actually have a blast doing these things as opposed to having them feel like a chore. : atom519
• toggle

  Protip: switching from Horse-centric to Camera-centric controls in the options makes riding 10x more enjo... : silent prophet
  • toggle

    I need to remember to try this. : atom519
    • At first I was like "wait, the horse is just going to always move in the direction the camera is facing? ... : silent prophet
  • toggle

    I tried it out for a while and didn't notice much difference. It basically makes it so the horse turns t... : MaxPete82
    • toggle

      Yes. I noticed it made turning and complicated maneuvers a lot easier though. Part of that may be because... : silent prophet
      • toggle

        I need to give it a little more time, it sounds like it could be more natural. : MaxPete82
        • toggle

          Definitely try it out. For the first minute or so, I was like "ehhh", but after 10 minutes, I realized I ... : silent prophet
          • The problem I had with the default was the horse would tend to turn the opposite direction to get to wher... : Sailor of Fortune
  • toggle

    Can you explain exactly what this does? I see this thread posted everyday but I've yet to find the defaul... : zuff
    • toggle

      Basically instead of trying to turn the horse with your left stick to get it to point in the direction yo... : silent prophet
      • toggle

        So it turns it into standard 3rd person shooter controls. That's a very good thing. : kingdepork
        • yes, exactly. Feels like the driving controls for tons of other games now. : silent prophet
      • toggle

        wouldn't that cause problems if you are being pursued by bandits and you want your horse to keep charging... : riptyde
        • All you have to do is rotate the left stick in the opposite way the camera is moving to keep riding in th... : silent prophet
    • And I'm not sure if I'll like this since a lot of the time when I'm riding around I like to rotate the ca... : at0micgarden
  • toggle

    aka halo warthog mode? : jake
    • Kinda... except the warthog ties acceleration to the directional analog stick too, doesn't it? That makes... : silent prophet
  • YES. I recommeded this last night and it makes the horse behave more like the Warthog. Great for shooting... : Sailor of Fortune
  • toggle

    how the hell do you STOP the horse? i end up running people over and going about 600 more feet from where... : Ulfie
    • toggle

      hold down the right shoulder button. : stump
      • ^^^^^ : silent prophet
      • *sigh* i was doing everything BUT that! thanks. : Ulfie
• toggle

  RDR would be damn near perfect if it had a loot system and your decisions could impact the game. The pro... : jake
  • toggle

    I would love the same things, but you know what's interesting? For all the discussion and marketing of th... : silent prophet
    • toggle

      RPG really is a misnomer at this point. You guys are asking for more carrots on more sticks. Loot systems... : Toth21
      • toggle

        I wouldn't mind seeing a more robust character progression system with the ability to specialize in skill : silent prophet
        • toggle

          Hmm thats the sort of RPG I can get behind. Yeah that would be awesome, but I'm really not expecting that... : Toth21
          • toggle

            Didn't San Andreas have a ton of stats to worry about? : Vincent Grayson
            • toggle

              It did, although it was handled pretty well I think. Ride a bike enough and your bike skill improves so ... : riptyde
              • toggle

                I loved crackdown's method for leveling up, I think it's nearly perfect for sandbox games. Prototype had... : dedgecko
                • toggle

                  The agility orbs was very well implemented in Crackdown. Want to get an agility orb? Gotta use the newf... : riptyde
                  • Yeah. The only change I would've made is to make it more incremental. Like, let each orb increase your ju... : Vincent Grayson
• toggle

  How do I give someone a ride when they ask? : Bamtan
  • not much action is required on your part for that event. : darcspeed
• toggle

  So one of the bonuses to pre-ordering RDR was getting a $20 gift card from Amazon, right? Where do I fin... : Zollington
  • toggle

    it gets automatically applied to your order the next time you buy a video game there : wtf242
    • It didn't, though... : Zollington
    • toggle

      No it doesn't. It's a gift card. : pancake humper
      • toggle

        So, are they going to be mailing that to me, or will I get an email eventually? : Zollington
        • toggle

          You will be getting an email notifying you that it has been credited to your account. It takes a week or... : MaxPete82
          • toggle

            Ah okay cool. : Zollington
            • toggle

              Don't worry, you're not the only one who hasn't gotten their $20 GC from Amazon yet. : hussdelrio
              • I was just kind of worried because on other stuff I've gotten the credit as soon as I made the pre-order.... : Zollington
• toggle

  I just beat the game and it was awesome all the way through. My biggest gripe is that there are quite a ... : swimteampie
  • I'm still early in the game and I just keep wishing for more gunfights in unique locations. Shooting peop... : Vincent Grayson
• Fucking shackhype. For once it's correct. TBH I'm having more fun with RDR than I did with GTA4. : Fyunch Click
• toggle

  What aiming system is everyone using? I defaulted to expert. : brickmatt
  • It was set to normal by default for me, and I think it works fine for me. : MaxPete82
  • toggle

    i set mine to casual because i am a pussy : oHnOES
    • I had problems with casual aming, it seems to stick like glue to center mass of your target. So once they... : swimteampie