The Fallout of EA and Take-Two's Falling Out

13
Over the weekend, publisher Electronic Arts announced that it was ending its attempted merger with Take-Two. With Take-Two's stock diving by roughly 25 percent, the financial world is buzzing with the news that Take-Two may be in some trouble after the closed-door negotiations collapsed.

Chris Morris of Forbes points out that in a five-month timespan, 2004's Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas actually outsold this year's blockbuster Grand Theft Auto 4 by a margin of 5.5 million to 4.8 million. A margin of less than one million copies may sound insignificant, but the greatly increased production costs involved in GTA4 mean that its premature sales slowdown isn't good news for Take-Two's profits.

Analyst Michael Pachter has another number to add to Take-Two's headaches: the Houser brothers have five months left on their contracts. As relayed by GamesIndustry, Sam and Dan Houser, producers of the GTA series, can expect to command more pay in their new contracts in February 2009. According to Pachter, Take-Two faces two options, both bad: the brothers either take a high bid from a competing publisher, leaving the GTA series without its rockstar auteurs, or they stay with the publisher but cost more money, eating into the company's profits.

If it seems odd to a gamer that news about a publisher centers on one game, it's deeply unsettling to investors. "What worries me is [Electronic Arts] saw everything [Take-Two] has in the pipeline and weren't impressed enough to make an upgraded offer," wrote Morris on a Shacknews comment predicting the stock plunge.

From The Chatty
  • reply
    September 15, 2008 12:42 PM

    What are the odds that the Housers end up at EA?

    • reply
      September 15, 2008 12:53 PM

      I hope they don't, cause I can't see EA ever releasing a game like GTA, at least not without watering it down quite a bit..

      • reply
        September 15, 2008 1:00 PM

        That's an odd thing to say, considering the whole reason for this sequence of events is that EA wanted to release a game very much like GTA--in fact, they wanted to release GTA itself.

      • reply
        September 15, 2008 1:49 PM

        Watering down how? Dead Space?

        • reply
          September 15, 2008 4:27 PM

          he's posting from his super-awesome ISDN from the past!!

    • reply
      September 15, 2008 1:56 PM

      I don't think that it is likely at all. It's just Pachter that consistently points that out.
      The Housers has the best contract in the industry, making a lot of money each release of GTA.
      If they end up at EA, they have to form a new studio, make new tech, create a new IP and they have to compete with GTA. If they stay, they will own that genre completely.

      The last contract alos involved a lot of stocks, so they will also take a big hit financially if they leave.

      And I don't think EA will pay them much more than they do to Will Wright or the Bioware Guys.

Hello, Meet Lola