• Join Us |
  • |
  • Sign in with:

Gibson Sues Six Retailers for Selling Guitar Hero; GameStop, Amazon, Wal-Mart and Others Named

by Chris Faylor, Mar 21, 2008 11:05am PDT
Related Topics – Guitar Hero, Activision, lawsuit

Update: In its legal filings, Gibson named the six retailers it is targeting for their sales of Guitar Hero: GameStop, Amazon.com, Wal-Mart, Target, Toys "R" Us and Kmart.

Original Story: Guitar manufacturer Gibson has announced that it is pursuing legal action against unspecified retailers for selling publisher Activision's popular Guitar Hero line of music video games, an action that Gibson claims infringes on one of its patents.

"Gibson Guitar took this action reluctantly, but is required to protect its intellectual property and will continue to do so against any other person in accordance with the law and its rights," the company proclaimed in a statement.

Earlier this year, Gibson began claiming that Activision's Guitar Hero games violate a 1999 patent for technology that simulates a concert performance via pre-recorded audio and a musical instrument.

Gibson had previously granted Activision and subsidiary RedOctane the license to use Gibson instruments in the Guitar Hero games, and as a model for the series' guitar-shaped controllers.

In response, Activision filed a lawsuit seeking to invalidate Gibson's patent, saying that Guitar Hero does not violate the patent and that the three-year delay between the debut of Guitar Hero and Gibson's allegation has granted the company an implied license.

"Gibson had tried to settle this issue by negotiating directly with Activision as soon as the patent filed through one of Gibson's divisions was discovered and validated by outside counsel," the company's statement continued.

"Activision chose to initiate litigation without notice to Gibson. Now Gibson must pursue enforcement of its patent which predates the launch of the Guitar Hero game by several years."

Activision released its response to the lawsuit earlier today, before Gibson's public announcement of the legal action.

"Our Guitar Hero retailing partners have done nothing wrong," claimed Activision. "We will confront this and any other efforts by Gibson to wrongfully interfere with Activision's relationship with its customers and its consumers.

"Activision continues to believe that Gibson's claims are disingenuous and lack any justification," Activision's statement continued. "Gibson waited three years to make its patent allegations, and only did so after it became clear that Activision was not interested in renewing its marketing and support agreement with Gibson.

"Gibson's lawsuit is a transparent end run around an impartial court that Activision asked on March 11 to rule on patent assertions that Gibson knows have no merit."





Comments

36 Threads | 83 Comments


























  • It's sad to see this direction. Guitar Hero has single handedly gotten the American youth interested in playing guitar (even if they don't stick with real guitar). It would be nice to see the music industry not strangling itself.

    Gibson's patent is also moronic. Karaoke machines have been doing this for years (a person's voice is a musical instrument). In addition, a Guitar Hero controller is just that: a controller. It is not a musical instrument in it of itself. Even after all of this, they have the problem of what exactly they patented. So they own the rights to having a program that plays a sound if you hit a button on key and plays a different sound if you hit it offkey? That basic idea has been used in video games for years. Back to the Future for the NES had a gameplay element where you had to move your character to collect musical notes to play a song so McFly's parents would hook up at the dance: that's about the same thing that they patented (synthesized music vs live music, I guess, but it's still pre-created).