New game releases of May 20-26
Killzone: Mercenary shoots onto Vita on September 10
Trion Worlds hit with more layoffs, Defiance team impacted
Ratchet & Clank: Full Frontal Assault defending Vita next week
Game & Wario was originally going to be pre-installed on Wii U
CNET Denies 'External Pressure' Caused Gerstmann Termination
by Chris Faylor, Nov 30, 2007 7:26pm PSTUpdate: Over on the blog, we have some interesting comments left on Silicon Valley gossip rag Valleywag claiming to be from a GameSpot editor. We have reason to believe they're legit, but since we can't definitively confirm it we're keeping it relegated to that part of the site.
Original story (Nov 30, 2007 5:14pm CST): GameSpot owner CNET has addressed allegations that GameSpot executive editor Jeff Gerstmann was fired due to his negative review of IO Interactive's Kane & Lynch: Dead Men (PC, PS3, X360), which is published by CNET advertising partner Eidos.
"We do not terminate employees based on external pressure from advertisers," CNET spokesperson Sarah Cain told Joystiq, though she refused to specify if Eidos had attempted any such pressure.
Though Gerstmann was far from the only one to paint a critically negative picture of IO Interactive's latest--for example, check out our own review of the game--many believe Eidos was upset with his take given that it had heavily advertised Kane & Lynch on GameSpot, to the point where the page could be understandably mistaken for the official Kane & Lynch site.
Said ads were removed from the site shortly after the story broke, as was Gerstmann's particularly harsh video review of the game. When asked why the video review was taken down, Cain noted that the text review now includes a note reading, "this review has been updated to include differences between the Xbox 360 and PS3 versions and a clarification on the game's multiplayer mode."
Cain refused to elaborate as to why the video review could not be edited in a similar manner.
The latest round of rumors suggest that Gerstmann's termination may be a result of multiple incidents in this vein, and was not caused by one sole act.
Comments
Ever since Kasavin left Gamespot, review scores have been so off the wall and outrageous, mainly because all the big games which kasavin would review, were now being reviewed by Gerstmen. I had been notcing this for a while, and when Gerstman made some stupid stupid comments about EA Skate on a podcast, I had to go say something on their forums.
So I just left a long winded rant about how he had no idea what he was talking about, and how Skate is the best thing to happen to skateboarding games, and is a work of art. I also talked a lot about how I thought Gerstmen was just a poor reviewer, and that now it had become clear since he starts getting more of the bigger games since Kasavin left.
I didn't go back after posting it, and in no way do I think what I said had anything to do with this firing, but I'm just noting that this was a long time comin imo. Gerstman was clueless.
Regarding Kane and Lynch, I have no idea if his review was accurate or not...
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 9 replies.
You must be logged in to post.