GRAW Developers Say PS3 Ain't So Bad; Carmack: You Be Illin'
by Nick Breckon, Aug 17, 2007 3:23pm PDTThe long-standing belief that the PlayStation 3's Cell processor is a developer's nightmare when compared to the working with the Xbox 360 has been challenged by Yann Le Tensorer, co-founder of Ubisoft TiWak. "It's wrong to say it's harder to code on the PlayStation 3. It's just something that needs to be learnt," said Le Tensorer to GamesIndustry. Le Tensorer is the co-creator of the YETI engine used in Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (PC, X360) and the upcoming Beowulf (PC, PS3, X360, PSP). "It's not harder to develop on the PS3 than it is on the 360, it's just a different console," he added. "Developers might say it's harder because it just takes time to understand the technology. We're still early in the lifecycle." At this year's QuakeCon, id's resident gangsta John Carmack acknowledged that his company's new engine id Tech 5 may potentially evolve into a more robust form on the PlayStation 3 than on the Xbox 360. However, Carmack also noted that in id's experience, the work required to program on the PlayStation 3 far exceeds that of any other platform. "360 and PS3 are more similar than any two gaming platforms ever," Carmack said. "But if you have a problem moving [a game] over, it's probably going to be because of the PS3." Cumbersome hardware has been the rumored blame for many PlayStation 3 delays, most recently Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto IV, which was pushed back from a November date into next year. At the time, industry analyst Michael Pachter was quoted as saying: "We think it is likely that the Rockstar team had difficulty in building an exceptionally complicated game for the PS3, and failed to recognise how far away from completion the game truly was until recently." But the team at Ubisoft maintains that a learning curve is only natural, no matter the platform. "If you take the PS2 for example, when God of War come out people saw it was tremendous," commented Ubisoft manager Adrian Lacey. "But it wasn't until the end of the PS2 cycle that we've seen the machine being pushed to its fullest."
Daily Filter: The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Enhanced Edition, MLB 12: The Show
Cradle trailer shows off Russian indie adventure game
WoW Monopoly, StarCraft RISK announced at Toy Fair
Jersey Shore's 'The Situation' signs App deal
Blacklight: Retribution open beta begins Feb 27
Comments
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 28 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 7 replies.
The 360 has advantages over the PS3 in terms of: unified memory, you can choose how the 512 megs is used for graphics ( uncached ) or normal memory (cached ), 6 general threads that have full access to memory, superior compiler, superior tools, easier upgrade of revisions, better documentation and samples.
I'm not counting the blue ray vs dvd debate in all of this, as that doesn't really impact my day to day development operation of using the kits.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 7 replies.
Now when we start seeing some of the stuff you can only get on the PS3 I'll buy it...or when the all Silver one comes out (because I'm shallow and I want one all silver and I figure if there's nothing on there to make me want it bad...I'll wait until I can get it in silver to match a lot of other stuff in my room (PC, 360 faceplate, trim of my furniture, TV, etc)). Sony really missed their chance to sell me one on day one though...if they'd allowed region free backwards compatibility I would have bought it as soon as I could (though I'm in a niche there and it wouldn't have sold too many new systems to have that).
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.
In the end there it really comes down to a balance between finesse and limits, and the PS3 has something to offer on both sides. If you know how to structure your application around the benefits of the CPU/GPU architecture, I actually could see it being easier to develop for, for a specific type of title. The thing is, that just isn't going to be the case most of the time when it comes down to the practicality of the matter, and the fact that game developers on the whole are not adjusted to that kind of architecture. Not to mention just about everything anyone does these days is going to be hitting its head on the memory ceiling (and a lot of that is textures, which works in the PS3 architecture, but that isn't always the big bottleneck).
What has this Yann guy done? Ghost Recon stopped mattering to me after the first one. This arcade-like mess isn't as fun to me as the original was.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 5 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 3 replies.
Thread Truncated. Click to see all 2 replies.